Patten S B, Brandon-Christie J, Devji J, Sedmak B
Department of Psychiatry, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, T2N 4N1, Canada.
Chronic Dis Can. 2000;21(2):68-72.
Recently, short-form versions of structured psychiatric diagnostic interviews have been developed for epidemiologic and survey research. These short forms can reduce research costs in large-scale studies; however, their accuracy is likely to be less than that of a full diagnostic interview. We evaluated the positive and negative predictive values of a short-form interview derived from the Composite International Diagnostic Interview (CIDI). Samples of subjects who scored both positively (n = 277) and negatively (n = 136) on the CIDI Short Form for Major Depression (CIDI-SFMD) were administered the full depressive disorders section of the CIDI. Almost all subjects who were negative on the short form were similarly classified as not having major depression by the CIDI. Approximately 25% of subjects had false positive results; these subjects tended to be older and less educated than true positives. Approximately 75% of subjects scoring five or more on the CIDI-SFMD had major depression according to the full CIDI, and a proportion of the remainder had less severe depressive syndromes. Some CIDI- SFMD positive subjects may have had depressive symptoms attributable to organic or other etiologies excluded under the definition of major depression.
最近,为了开展流行病学和调查研究,已开发出结构化精神科诊断访谈的简短版本。这些简短版本可降低大规模研究的成本;然而,其准确性可能低于完整诊断访谈。我们评估了源自综合国际诊断访谈(CIDI)的简短访谈的阳性和阴性预测值。对在《CIDI 抑郁症简短量表》(CIDI-SFMD)上得分呈阳性(n = 277)和阴性(n = 136)的受试者样本进行了CIDI完整的抑郁症部分的测试。几乎所有在简短量表上呈阴性的受试者在CIDI中也同样被归类为没有重度抑郁症。约25%的受试者有假阳性结果;这些受试者往往比真阳性受试者年龄更大且受教育程度更低。根据完整的CIDI,在CIDI-SFMD上得分为5分或更高的受试者中约75%患有重度抑郁症,其余部分中有一部分患有不太严重的抑郁综合征。一些CIDI-SFMD呈阳性的受试者可能有归因于器质性或其他病因的抑郁症状,这些症状在重度抑郁症的定义中被排除。