Boerma W G, van den Brink-Muinen A
NIVEL, Netherlands Institute of Primary Health Care, Utrecht.
Med Care. 2000 Oct;38(10):993-1002. doi: 10.1097/00005650-200010000-00003.
The number of women entering general practice is rising in many countries. Thus, gender differences in work situation preferences and practice activities are important for future planning.
This article describes the differences between male and female general practitioners (GPs) in 32 European countries. It examines gender differences in curative and preventive services and relates these to features of the health care system and the practice.
The data were collected in 1993 and 1994 in the European Study of Task Profiles of General Practitioners. In 32 countries, 8,183 GPs answered standardized questionnaires written in their own languages on their self-reported involvement in curative and preventive services, as well as how their practice was organized and managed. Because the independent variables in this study were on both the national 1 and individual practice levels, the data were subjected to multilevel analysis.
Regardless of the type of health care system, the female GPs were younger than the male GPs and more often worked part time in groups or partnerships and in cities, although not in deprived areas. They made fewer house calls and did less work outside office hours. Differences between men and women regarding workload diminished considerably after controlling for part-time work. When other characteristics of the person and the practice were taken into account, female GPs proved to be less involved in several curative services, except as the first contact for gynecological problems, but more involved in health education. Some differences were found in only certain types of health care systems.
The results may have important implications for working arrangements, training, education, and planning of resources for general practice in the future.
在许多国家,进入全科医疗领域的女性人数正在增加。因此,工作状况偏好和执业活动中的性别差异对于未来规划至关重要。
本文描述了32个欧洲国家男女全科医生之间的差异。研究了治疗性和预防性服务中的性别差异,并将这些差异与医疗保健系统及执业的特征联系起来。
数据于1993年和1994年在欧洲全科医生任务概况研究中收集。在32个国家,8183名全科医生用各自的语言回答了标准化问卷,内容涉及他们自我报告的在治疗性和预防性服务中的参与情况,以及他们的执业组织和管理方式。由于本研究中的自变量涉及国家和个体执业两个层面,因此对数据进行了多层面分析。
无论医疗保健系统类型如何,女性全科医生比男性全科医生年轻,更常以兼职形式在团体或合伙诊所工作,且工作地点在城市,但不在贫困地区。她们上门出诊较少,非办公时间的工作也较少。在控制了兼职工作因素后,男女工作量的差异大幅减小。考虑到个人和执业的其他特征后,女性全科医生除了作为妇科问题的首诊医生外,在一些治疗性服务中的参与度较低,但在健康教育方面的参与度较高。仅在某些类型的医疗保健系统中发现了一些差异。
这些结果可能对未来全科医疗的工作安排、培训、教育和资源规划具有重要意义。