Churchill A, Hopkins B, Rönnqvist L, Vogt S
Department of Psychology, Lancaster University, UK.
Exp Brain Res. 2000 Sep;134(1):81-9. doi: 10.1007/s002210000444.
Previous findings on the role of visual contact with the hand in the control of reaching and grasping have been contradictory. Some studies have shown that such contact is largely irrelevant, while more recent ones have emphasised its importance. In contrast, information arising from the surrounding environment has received relatively little attention in the study of prehensile actions. In order to identify the roles of both sources of information, we made kinematic comparisons between three conditions. In the first, reaching was performed in a dimly lit room and compared with a second condition in which reaches in the dark, but with the thumb and first finger illuminated, were made to a luminous object. This contrast allows the effects of environmental context to be identified. A comparison between the second and a third condition, in which both vision of the hand and the environment was removed, but the object was still visually available, enabled the assessment of how and when vision of the hand plays a role. Removing environmental cues had effects both early and late in the reach, while vision of the hand was only crucial in the period after peak deceleration. In addition, removal of both sources of information resulted in larger grip apertures. Differences and similarities between our findings and those of other studies are discussed, as is the ongoing debate about the relative importance of visual feedback of the hand in the control and co-ordination of prehensile actions. We conclude with suggestions for further research based on the set-up used in the present study.
先前关于手部视觉接触在伸手和抓握控制中所起作用的研究结果相互矛盾。一些研究表明这种接触在很大程度上无关紧要,而最近的研究则强调了其重要性。相比之下,在对抓握动作的研究中,来自周围环境的信息受到的关注相对较少。为了确定这两种信息来源的作用,我们对三种情况进行了运动学比较。第一种情况是在光线昏暗的房间里伸手,将其与第二种情况进行比较,即在黑暗中伸手,但拇指和食指被照亮,伸向一个发光物体。这种对比可以确定环境背景的影响。将第二种情况与第三种情况进行比较,在第三种情况中,手部和环境的视觉都被去除,但物体在视觉上仍然可见,这样就能评估手部视觉如何以及何时发挥作用。去除环境线索在伸手的早期和后期都有影响,而手部视觉仅在减速峰值后的时间段内至关重要。此外,去除这两种信息来源会导致更大的抓握孔径。我们讨论了我们的研究结果与其他研究结果之间的异同,以及关于手部视觉反馈在抓握动作控制和协调中的相对重要性的持续争论。我们基于本研究中使用的设置,给出了进一步研究的建议作为结论。