Tully D B, Collins B J, Overstreet J D, Smith C S, Dinse G E, Mumtaz M M, Chapin R E
Environmental Toxicology Program, National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences, Research Triangle Park, North Carolina, 27709, USA.
Toxicol Appl Pharmacol. 2000 Oct 15;168(2):79-90. doi: 10.1006/taap.2000.9014.
Toxic metals occur naturally at low concentrations throughout the environment, but are found in higher concentrations at many of the hazardous waste sites on the EPA Superfund list. As part of the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) mandate to evaluate the toxicity of metals and mixtures, we chose four of the high-priority metal pollutants from ATSDR's HAZDAT list, including arsenic, cadmium, chromium, and lead, to test in a commercially developed assay system, CAT-Tox(L) (Xenometrix). This assay employs a battery of recombinant HepG2 cell lines to test the transcriptional activation capacity of xenobiotics in any of 13 different signal transduction pathways. Our specific aims were to identify metal-responsive promoters and determine whether the pattern of gene expression changed with a mixture of metals. Humic acid was used in all assays as a carrier to help solubilize the metals and, in all cases, the cells were exposed to the humic acid-metal mixture for 48 h. Humic acid alone, at 50-100 microM, showed moderate activation of the XRE promoter, but little other notable activity. As(V), at doses of 50-250 microM, produced a complex profile of activity showing significant dose-dependent induction of the hMTIIA, GST Ya, HSP70, FOS, XRE, NFkappaBRE, GADD153, p53RE, and CRE promoters. Pb(II) showed dose-related induction of the GST Ya, XRE, hMTIIA, GRP78, and CYP IA1 promoters at doses in the range of 12-100 microM. Cd(II), at 1.25-15 microM, yielded significant dose-dependent induction of hMTIIA, XRE, CYP IA1, GST Ya, HSP70, NFkappaBRE, and FOS. Whereas Cr(III) yielded small, though significant inductions of the CRE, FOS, GADD153, and XRE promoters only at the highest dose (750 microM), Cr(VI) produced significant dose-related inductions of the p53RE, FOS, NFkappaBRE, XRE, GADD45, HSP70, and CRE promoters at much lower doses, in the range of 5-10 microM. Assays testing serial dilutions of a mixture comprising 7.5 microM Cd(II), 750 microM Cr(III), and 100 microM Pb(II) (the combination of metals most frequently found at National Priority List sites) showed significant dose-dependent induction of the hMTIIA promoter, but failed to show dose-related induction of any other promoter and showed no evidence of synergistic activation of gene expression by the metals in this mixture. Our results thus show metal activation of gene expression through several previously unreported signal transduction pathways, including As(V) induction of GST Ya, FOS, XRE, NFkBRE, GADD153, p53RE, and CRE; Pb(II) induction of GST Ya, XRE, Cyp IA1, and GADD153; Cd(II) induction of NFkBRE, Cyp IA1, XRE, and GST Ya; and Cr(VI) induction of p53RE, XRE, GADD45, HSP70, and CRE promoters, and thus suggest new insights into the biochemical mechanisms of toxicity and carcinogenicity of metals. It is also an important finding that no evidence of synergistic activity was detected with the mixture of Cd(II), Cr(III), and Pb(II) tested in these assays.
有毒金属在整个环境中天然存在,浓度较低,但在美国环境保护局超级基金名单上的许多危险废物场地中浓度较高。作为有毒物质和疾病登记处(ATSDR)评估金属及混合物毒性任务的一部分,我们从ATSDR的HAZDAT名单中选择了四种高优先级金属污染物,包括砷、镉、铬和铅,在一种商业开发的检测系统CAT-Tox(L)(Xenometrix)中进行测试。该检测采用一系列重组HepG2细胞系,以测试异生物素在13种不同信号转导途径中任何一种途径的转录激活能力。我们的具体目标是识别金属反应性启动子,并确定基因表达模式是否会因金属混合物而改变。在所有检测中均使用腐殖酸作为载体,以帮助溶解金属,并且在所有情况下,细胞都暴露于腐殖酸-金属混合物中48小时。单独的腐殖酸,浓度为50-100微摩尔,对XRE启动子有适度激活,但几乎没有其他显著活性。五价砷(As(V)),剂量为50-250微摩尔,产生了复杂的活性谱,显示出对hMTIIA、GST Ya、HSP70、FOS、XRE、NFκBRE、GADD153、p53RE和CRE启动子有显著的剂量依赖性诱导。二价铅(Pb(II))在12-100微摩尔范围内的剂量下,显示出对GST Ya、XRE、hMTIIA、GRP78和CYP IA1启动子的剂量相关诱导。二价镉(Cd(II)),浓度为1.25-15微摩尔,对hMTIIA、XRE、CYP IA1、GST Ya、HSP70、NFκBRE和FOS产生显著的剂量依赖性诱导。而三价铬(Cr(III))仅在最高剂量(750微摩尔)时对CRE、FOS、GADD153和XRE启动子有小但显著的诱导,六价铬(Cr(VI))在低得多的剂量(5-10微摩尔范围内)对p53RE、FOS、NFκBRE、XRE、GADD45、HSP70和CRE启动子产生显著的剂量相关诱导。对包含7.5微摩尔Cd(II)、750微摩尔Cr(III)和100微摩尔Pb(II)(在国家优先名单场地中最常发现的金属组合)的混合物进行系列稀释检测,结果显示对hMTIIA启动子有显著的剂量依赖性诱导,但未显示对任何其他启动子的剂量相关诱导,并且没有证据表明该混合物中的金属对基因表达有协同激活作用。因此,我们的结果表明金属通过几种先前未报道的信号转导途径激活基因表达,包括As(V)对GST Ya、FOS、XRE、NFκBRE、GADD153、p53RE和CRE的诱导;Pb(II)对GST Ya、XRE、Cyp IA1和GADD153的诱导;Cd(II)对NFκBRE、Cyp IA1、XRE和GST Ya的诱导;以及Cr(VI)对p53RE、XRE、GADD45、HSP70和CRE启动子的诱导,从而为金属毒性和致癌性的生化机制提供了新的见解。在这些检测中测试的Cd(II)、Cr(III)和Pb(II)混合物未检测到协同活性的证据,这也是一项重要发现。