Wiles N J, Dunn G, Barrett E M, Harrison B J, Silman A J, Symmons D P
ARC Epidemiology Unit, University of Manchester Medical School, UK.
J Rheumatol. 2000 Oct;27(10):2360-6.
To compare the accuracy of simple demographic and clinical variables recorded at baseline with those recorded after one year followup, in predicting self-reported functional disability recorded 5 years after initial assessment in patients with early inflammatory polyarthritis (IP).
We followed annually for 5 years 528 patients registered by the Norfolk Arthritis Register (a primary care based cohort of patients with early IP) using the Health Assessment Questionnaire (HAQ). Backward stepwise logistic regression was used to determine the clinical and demographic variables, collected at either baseline or first followup, that were associated with disability (HAQ > or = 1.00/> or =1.50) at 5 years.
At the 5th anniversary assessment, the prevalence of moderate disability (HAQ > or = 1.00) was 47%. Twenty-nine percent reported more severe disability (HAQ > or = 1.50). Variables recorded at first anniversary assessment were better able to predict patients at risk of developing a poor outcome than baseline variables. Multivariate methods identified age at symptom onset, HAQ score, presence of nodules, and a statistically derived factor describing joint tenderness recorded at first year as important predictors of both moderate disability (HAQ > or =1.00) and a higher level of disability (HAQ > or = 1.50). When tested in an independent validation sample, the accuracy of the models generated from data recorded at the first year was 76% (HAQ > or = 1.00) and 83% (HAQ > or = 1.50).
It was possible to predict disability at 5 years with high accuracy using simple clinical variables and demographic data collected 4 or 5 years previously. First year HAQ score was the strongest predictor of future disability. HAQ score at 5 years could be predicted more accurately using data collected at first anniversary visit than using data recorded at baseline.
比较早期炎症性多关节炎(IP)患者初始评估后5年自我报告的功能残疾情况,评估基线时记录的简单人口统计学和临床变量与1年随访后记录的变量在预测功能残疾方面的准确性。
我们使用健康评估问卷(HAQ)对诺福克关节炎登记处(一个基于初级保健的早期IP患者队列)登记的528例患者进行了为期5年的年度随访。采用向后逐步逻辑回归来确定在基线或首次随访时收集的、与5年时的残疾情况(HAQ≥1.00/≥1.50)相关的临床和人口统计学变量。
在第5周年评估时,中度残疾(HAQ≥1.00)的患病率为47%。29%的患者报告有更严重的残疾(HAQ≥1.50)。与基线变量相比,首次周年评估时记录的变量能更好地预测有不良结局风险的患者。多变量方法确定症状出现时的年龄、HAQ评分、结节的存在以及第一年记录的描述关节压痛的一个统计学推导因素是中度残疾(HAQ≥1.00)和更高水平残疾(HAQ≥1.50)的重要预测因素。在独立验证样本中进行测试时,根据第一年记录的数据生成的模型的准确性为76%(HAQ≥1.00)和83%(HAQ≥1.50)。
使用4或5年前收集的简单临床变量和人口统计学数据可以高精度预测5年时的残疾情况。第一年的HAQ评分是未来残疾的最强预测因素。与使用基线记录的数据相比,使用首次周年访视时收集的数据能更准确地预测5年时的HAQ评分。