Engel J, Anteunis L, Chenault M, Marres E
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Head and Neck Surgery, University Hospital Maastricht, The Netherlands.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2000;257(7):366-71. doi: 10.1007/s004050000239.
To determine the value of different otoscopic findings in diagnosing otitis media with effusion, 3,780 otological examinations of 250 infants at ages 0-2 years were compared with tympanometric findings. Otoscopy was performed by an experienced otologist and research-audiologist prior to tympanometry. The following success rates for these procedures were found: otoscopy, 85-91%, tympanometry, 74-94%, either otoscopy or tympanometry, 89-99%. "Glue" was noted as the most frequent abnormal otoscopic feature, i.e., depending on age, 6-32%. Fluid line/ bubbles, bulging/hyperaemia or otorrhoea were rarely (0-5%) observed and contributed little to the diagnosis of otitis media with effusion. No structural changes of the tympanic membrane were observed. Analysis of tympanometric data revealed that the prevalence of tympanogram types B (21-44%), C1 (0.5-16%) and C2 (0-8%) was age-dependent. Comparison of otoscopic and tympanometric findings indicated sufficient diagnostic agreement (Cohen's kappa between 0.41 and 0.74) at age 6-24 months. In conclusion, otoscopy appears to be a valid instrument for diagnosing otitis media with effusion, at least from 6 to 24 months of age. In addition, the results of our study suggest that tuba-dysfunction and otitis media with effusion are age-dependent disorders during infancy, without structural effects on the tympanic membrane.
为了确定不同耳镜检查结果在诊断分泌性中耳炎中的价值,将250名0至2岁婴儿的3780次耳科检查结果与鼓室导抗图检查结果进行了比较。在进行鼓室导抗图检查之前,由一位经验丰富的耳科医生和研究听力学家进行耳镜检查。发现这些检查方法的成功率如下:耳镜检查为85 - 91%,鼓室导抗图检查为74 - 94%,耳镜检查或鼓室导抗图检查为89 - 99%。“胶耳”被认为是最常见的异常耳镜特征,即根据年龄不同,发生率为6 - 32%。很少(0 - 5%)观察到液平面/气泡、鼓膜膨出/充血或耳漏,这些对分泌性中耳炎的诊断贡献不大。未观察到鼓膜的结构变化。对鼓室导抗图数据的分析显示,B型(21 - 44%)、C1型(0.5 - 16%)和C2型(0 - 8%)鼓室导抗图的发生率与年龄有关。耳镜检查和鼓室导抗图检查结果的比较表明,在6至24个月龄时诊断一致性良好(科恩kappa系数在0.41至0.74之间)。总之,至少在6至24个月龄时,耳镜检查似乎是诊断分泌性中耳炎的有效手段。此外,我们的研究结果表明,咽鼓管功能障碍和分泌性中耳炎在婴儿期是与年龄相关的疾病,对鼓膜无结构影响。