Pedersen H K, Bakke S J, Hald J K, Skalpe I O, Anke I M, Sagsveen R, Langmoen I A, Lindegaard K E, Nakstad P H
Department of Radiology, The National Hospital, University of Oslo, Norway.
Acta Radiol. 2001 Jan;42(1):43-9.
Minimal- or non-invasive methods replacing intra-arterial digital subtraction angiography (IA-DSA) would be of great importance in patients suffering from acute subarachnoid haemorrhage (SAH). The aims of this study were to compare CTA with IA-DSA in patients with acute SAH, to compare CTA interpretations with those of blinded, independent reviewers and to evaluate improvement in CTA diagnostics after 1 year of experience with CTA.
During 2 years 162 patients with SAH underwent CTA as well as IA-DSA. Independent blinded review of 77 patients was performed for 1 year.
Totally 144 aneurysms were demonstrated in 119 patients at IA-DSA, while 43 patients had normal intracranial arteries. Initially 131 aneurysms were detected at CTA while 2 normal, tortuous arteries were misinterpreted as aneurysms, giving a sensitivity of 91% and a specificity of 95%. At independent blinded review the observer agreement was 87% and the kappa value 0.68.
CTA in SAH is of great value in demonstrating vascular anatomy and the exact size of an aneurysm. However, IA-DSA is still needed for diagnostic evaluation in aneurysms smaller than 5 mm in diameter, especially in those located near bony structures.
对于急性蛛网膜下腔出血(SAH)患者而言,能够替代动脉内数字减影血管造影(IA-DSA)的微创或无创方法具有重要意义。本研究的目的是比较急性SAH患者的CT血管造影(CTA)与IA-DSA,将CTA的解读与独立盲法评审人员的解读进行比较,并评估在积累1年CTA经验后CTA诊断的改善情况。
在2年时间里,162例SAH患者接受了CTA和IA-DSA检查。对77例患者进行了为期1年的独立盲法评审。
IA-DSA显示119例患者共有144个动脉瘤,而43例患者颅内动脉正常。CTA最初检测到131个动脉瘤,同时有2条正常的迂曲动脉被误诊为动脉瘤,敏感性为91%,特异性为95%。在独立盲法评审中,观察者一致性为87%,kappa值为0.68。
SAH患者的CTA在显示血管解剖结构和动脉瘤的确切大小时具有重要价值。然而,对于直径小于5mm的动脉瘤,尤其是位于骨结构附近的动脉瘤,诊断评估仍需要IA-DSA。