Holt J, Vold I N, Backe B, Johansen M V, Oian P
Department of Pediatrics, Nordland Central Hospital, Bodø, Norway.
Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2001 Mar;80(3):206-12.
As small obstetrical departments may not be able to give second-level perinatal care, the delivery unit at Lofoten hospital was for the years 1997-98 reorganized to a modified midwife managed unit. Women at low obstetrical risk were delivered at this unit and women at high risk were referred to the central hospital. We assessed the effectiveness of the risk selection.
The study was a prospective, pragmatic, population-based trial. Desired outcome was defined as a non-operative delivery at 35-42 weeks gestational age giving an infant not needing resuscitation. Intermediate outcomes: Operative deliveries, infants transferred to neonatal intensive care unit and infants diverging from normal. The intended place of delivery was ultimately decided at admittance to the midwife managed unit.
Of the 628 women in study 435 (69.3%) gave birth at the midwife managed unit, 152 (24.2%) were selected to be delivered at the central hospital and 41 (6.5%) were transferred to the central hospital after admittance to the midwife managed unit. Desired outcome was recorded in 94% of the deliveries at the midwife managed unit as compared to 50.3% at the central hospital. Women who intended to be delivered at the midwife managed unit, needed fewer operative deliveries and relatively few infants were transferred to the neonatal intensive care unit or diverged from normal.
As nearly 70% of the births occurred at the midwife managed unit and 94% of these deliveries had a desired outcome, this indicates an effective selection process. This model might be an alternative to centralization of births in sparsely population areas.
由于小型产科部门可能无法提供二级围产期护理,1997 - 1998年期间,罗弗敦医院的分娩单元被重组为改良的助产士管理单元。低产科风险的妇女在该单元分娩,高风险的妇女则被转诊至中心医院。我们评估了风险筛选的有效性。
该研究是一项前瞻性、务实、基于人群的试验。预期结果定义为孕35 - 42周时非手术分娩,且婴儿无需复苏。中间结果包括:手术分娩、转入新生儿重症监护病房的婴儿以及偏离正常情况的婴儿。最终的分娩地点在进入助产士管理单元时确定。
在628名研究对象中,435名(69.3%)在助产士管理单元分娩,152名(24.2%)被选定在中心医院分娩,41名(6.5%)在进入助产士管理单元后被转至中心医院。在助产士管理单元分娩的产妇中,94%达到了预期结果,而在中心医院这一比例为50.3%。打算在助产士管理单元分娩的妇女,手术分娩次数较少,相对较少的婴儿被转入新生儿重症监护病房或出现异常情况。
由于近70%的分娩在助产士管理单元进行,且其中94%的分娩达到了预期结果,这表明筛选过程是有效的。这种模式可能是人口稀少地区分娩集中化的一种替代方案。