Carpenter M J, Hughes J R, Solomon L J, Powell T A
Department of Psychiatry, University of Vermont, Burlington, Vermont 05401, USA.
Tob Control. 2001 Mar;10(1):38-42. doi: 10.1136/tc.10.1.38.
To assess level of endorsement and expected consequences of worksite smoking restriction policies among correctional employees.
Mailed survey to Vermont state correctional employees.
Support for various policy alternatives for both staff and inmate smoking; expected consequences of restrictive smoking policies and smoking behaviour.
321 of 640 (50%) state correctional employees responded.
Employees were somewhat receptive to smoking restrictions for inmates, but less supportive of staff smoking restrictions. A complete ban on inmate smoking both indoors and outdoors was supported by 56% and 49% of never and ex-smokers, respectively, but only 15% of current smokers (p < 0.01). A similar ban on employee smoking was supported by 38% of never and ex-smokers, but only 3% of current smokers (p < 0.01). Overall, employees were most supportive (52%) of a policy for themselves that banned indoor smoking and restricted it to certain areas outdoors. Current smokers were more likely to expect negative consequences as a result of further restrictions than were never or ex-smokers.
Although our findings are limited by a low response rate, most employees support an indoor ban, but not a total ban on smoking. Employees generally favoured a policy that was slightly more restrictive than the current policy, but were less supportive of tighter smoking restrictions for themselves. However, a more restrictive smoking policy is likely to result in some degree of resistance among current smoking employees, who may require specific attention to address their opposition.
评估惩教机构员工对工作场所吸烟限制政策的认可程度及预期后果。
对佛蒙特州惩教机构员工进行邮寄调查。
对员工和囚犯吸烟的各种政策选择的支持度;限制性吸烟政策的预期后果及吸烟行为。
640名州惩教机构员工中有321人(50%)回复。
员工对囚犯吸烟限制有所接受,但对员工吸烟限制支持度较低。完全禁止囚犯在室内和室外吸烟,从不吸烟者和曾经吸烟者分别有56%和49%表示支持,但当前吸烟者中只有15%表示支持(p<0.01)。类似的员工吸烟禁令,从不吸烟者和曾经吸烟者中有38%表示支持,但当前吸烟者中只有3%表示支持(p<0.01)。总体而言,员工最支持(52%)一项针对他们自己的政策,即禁止室内吸烟并将其限制在室外某些区域。与从不吸烟者或曾经吸烟者相比,当前吸烟者更有可能预期进一步限制会带来负面后果。
尽管我们的研究结果因回复率低而受到限制,但大多数员工支持室内禁烟,但不支持全面禁烟。员工普遍倾向于一项比现行政策稍严格的政策,但对自身更严格的吸烟限制支持度较低。然而,更严格的吸烟政策可能会在当前吸烟的员工中引发一定程度的抵制,可能需要特别关注以应对他们的反对。