Lynnerup N
Laboratory of Biological Anthropology, Institute of Forensic Pathology, University of Copenhagen, 1017, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Forensic Sci Int. 2001 Mar 1;117(1-2):45-51. doi: 10.1016/s0379-0738(00)00447-3.
The cranial thickness was measured in 64 individuals (43 males, 21 females) autopsied at our institute. The thickness was measured by taking a biopsy with a trephine at four specific locations on the skull. Complete medical records and pathologic autopsy results were available. While none of the individuals had suffered from diseases affecting bone or bone metabolism as such, a large sub group consisted of individuals with a history of, and autopsy finds consistent with, chronic substance and alcohol abuse. There was no statistically significant difference in cranial thickness measures between this group and the rest of the material. Subsequent analyses failed to reveal any correlations between the cranial thickness and sex and age and height and weight of the individual. This is in accordance with most earlier studies, which likewise show no correlation, or only very faint trends, between cranial thickness and these parameters. This study, thus, adds to other studies showing that cranial thickness cannot be used in aging or sexing human remains. Likewise, in a forensic pathological setting, cranial thickness cannot be inferred from the individuals stature and build, which may be an issue in cases of interpersonal violence with cranial trauma.
我们研究所对64例尸检者(43例男性,21例女性)的颅骨厚度进行了测量。通过使用环钻在颅骨的四个特定位置进行活检来测量厚度。完整的医疗记录和病理尸检结果均可得。虽然这些个体均未患有影响骨骼或骨代谢的疾病,但有一大部分亚组个体有慢性物质和酒精滥用史,且尸检结果与之相符。该组与其他材料之间的颅骨厚度测量值无统计学显著差异。后续分析未能揭示颅骨厚度与个体的性别、年龄、身高和体重之间的任何相关性。这与大多数早期研究一致,这些研究同样表明颅骨厚度与这些参数之间无相关性,或仅有非常微弱的趋势。因此,本研究补充了其他研究结果,表明颅骨厚度不能用于推断人类遗骸的年龄或性别。同样,在法医病理环境中,不能从个体的身高和体型推断颅骨厚度,这在涉及颅骨创伤的人际暴力案件中可能是一个问题。