Riepert T, Ulmcke D, Schweden F, Nafe B
Institute of Forensic Medicine of the Johannes Gutenberg University, Mainz, Germany.
Forensic Sci Int. 2001 Mar 1;117(1-2):89-98. doi: 10.1016/s0379-0738(00)00452-7.
The aim of the study was to improve the objectivity of X-ray image comparison for the identification of unknown dead individuals. CT-data were collected for 30 macerated skulls. An already presented computer program which uses CT data to establish virtual X-ray images was used to obtain X-rays with different beam angulations simulating rotation, dorsal flexion, and ventral flexion. Specific parameters were measured on the simulated images. The frontal sinus reveals the highest variability not only between the individual skulls but also within an individual skull in different positions. The most consistent parameters with respect to different positions were the skull breadth, the biorbital breadth and the bizygomatic breadth. In a blind study, three out of 24 skulls could clearly be identified just by measured distances although the positions were different and unknown to the investigator. The dimensions of the frontal sinus do not correlate with the other skull parameters (analysis of covariance). Based on the presented results, we propose a method that will calculate the probability of identity. The presented results demonstrate that the comparison of X-ray images can be undertaken in an objective way by quantifying the probability of identity even when the comparative images were made under different conditions.
本研究的目的是提高用于识别无名死者的X射线图像比较的客观性。收集了30个浸软颅骨的CT数据。使用一个已展示的利用CT数据建立虚拟X射线图像的计算机程序,来获取模拟旋转、背屈和腹屈的不同束角的X射线。在模拟图像上测量特定参数。额窦不仅在个体颅骨之间,而且在不同位置的单个颅骨内显示出最高的变异性。关于不同位置最一致的参数是颅骨宽度、双眶宽度和双颧宽度。在一项盲法研究中,尽管位置不同且研究者未知,但24个颅骨中有3个仅凭测量距离就能清晰识别。额窦的尺寸与其他颅骨参数不相关(协方差分析)。基于所呈现的结果,我们提出一种计算身份概率的方法。所呈现的结果表明,即使比较图像是在不同条件下制作的,通过量化身份概率,也可以客观地进行X射线图像的比较。