Costa E F, Miller B R, Pesti G M, Bakalli R I, Ewing H P
Department of Agricultural and Applied Economics, University of Georgia, Athens 30602-7509, USA.
Poult Sci. 2001 Mar;80(3):306-13. doi: 10.1093/ps/80.3.306.
Four experiments were conducted to compare the performance of broilers fed soybean meal (SBM) versus peanut meal (PNM) as protein sources. Ross x Ross 208 broiler chickens were placed in battery brooders (Experiments 1 to 3, four replicates of 8 chicks per treatment) and floor pens (Experiment 4, four replicates of 34 chicks per treatment). In Experiment 1, addition of 0, 0.1, 0.2, and 0.3% Thr to a corn-PNM-based diet increased 0 to 18 d BW gain (BWG; 0.374c vs. 0.495b vs. 0.508b vs. 0.508b kg, respectively) and decreased feed conversion ratio (FCR; 2.09c vs. 1.63b vs. vs. 1.54b vs. 1.54b g/g, respectively) compared to the corn-SBM-based control diet (BWG = 0.593a and FCR = 1.36a). In Experiment 2, diets were formulated with the same amino acid minimums, and as the percentage of PNM increased in the diets (0, 10, 20, and 32%), BWG decreased (0.560a vs. 0.532a vs. 0.521a vs. 0.458b kg, respectively) and FCR increased (1.72b vs. 1.71b vs. 1.79bc vs. 1.86c g/g, respectively). In Experiment 3, addition of Thr to a corn-PNM-based diet increased BWG (-Thr = 0.284c vs. +Thr = 0.397b kg) and decreased FCR (-Thr = 1.60b vs. +Thr = 1.54b g/g). The BWG and FCR were best for the corn-SBM-based control diet (0.499a kg and 1.38a g/g, respectively). In Experiment 4, during the growing period (18 to 42 d), significant interactions occurred between protein source (PNM vs. SBM) and protein level (16 and 20% vs. 24%) for BW and FCR but not for carcass, breast, or leg quarter yield or fat pad weights (P < 0.05) at 42 d of age. Technical (not economic) performance of birds fed PNM was similar to SBM at the highest protein levels fed. PNM could be used as a protein source for broilers under appropriate economic conditions.
进行了四项试验,比较以豆粕(SBM)和花生粕(PNM)作为蛋白质来源时肉鸡的生产性能。罗斯×罗斯208肉鸡饲养于层叠式育雏笼(试验1至3,每个处理8只雏鸡,重复4次)和地面平养栏(试验4,每个处理34只雏鸡,重复4次)。在试验1中,在以玉米 - PNM为基础的日粮中添加0、0.1、0.2和0.3%的苏氨酸,与以玉米 - SBM为基础的对照日粮相比(BW增重 = 0.593a,饲料转化率 = 1.36a),1至18日龄的体重增加量(BWG)分别提高(分别为0.374c、0.495b、0.508b、0.508b千克),饲料转化率(FCR)降低(分别为2.09c、1.63b、1.54b、1.54b克/克)。在试验2中,日粮按相同的氨基酸最低水平配制,随着日粮中PNM比例增加(0、10、20和32%),BWG降低(分别为0.560a、0.532a、0.521a、0.458b千克),FCR升高(分别为1.72b、1.71b、1.79bc、1.86c克/克)。在试验3中,在以玉米 - PNM为基础的日粮中添加苏氨酸提高了BWG(-苏氨酸 = 0.284c,+苏氨酸 = 0.397b千克)并降低了FCR(-苏氨酸 = 1.60b,+苏氨酸 = 1.54b克/克)。以玉米 - SBM为基础的对照日粮的BWG和FCR最佳(分别为0.499a千克和1.38a克/克)。在试验4中,在生长阶段(18至42日龄),蛋白质来源(PNM与SBM)和蛋白质水平(16%和20%与24%)之间在体重和饲料转化率方面存在显著交互作用,但在42日龄时胴体、胸肉或腿肉产量以及脂肪垫重量方面不存在交互作用(P < 0.05)。在最高蛋白质水平下,饲喂PNM的肉鸡的技术(而非经济)性能与饲喂SBM的肉鸡相似。在适当的经济条件下,PNM可作为肉鸡的蛋白质来源。