Liss M, Fein D, Allen D, Dunn M, Feinstein C, Morris R, Waterhouse L, Rapin I
University of Connecticut, Storrs, USA.
J Child Psychol Psychiatry. 2001 Feb;42(2):261-70.
Executive functioning was investigated in 34 children (24 boys and 10 girls) with developmental language disorder (DLD) and 21 children (18 boys and 3 girls) with high-functioning autistic disorder (HAD) matched on Full Scale IQ, Nonverbal IQ, age (mean age 9 year, 1 month), and SES. The DLD group had a Verbal IQ that was 10 points higher than the HAD group. These children were given the Wisconsin Card Sorting Test (WCST), the Mazes subtest from the WISC-R, the Underlining test, and the Rapid Automatized Naming test. In addition, these children were given the Vineland Scales of Adaptive Functioning and the Wing Diagnostic Symptom Checklist in order to assess severity of autistic symptomatology. Results indicated that the only significant difference between the two groups on the cognitive tasks was perseverative errors on the WCST; there was no significant difference on total number of categories achieved or total number of errors on the WCST or on the other executive function measures. There was also significant overlap in the scores between the two groups and the difference in perseverative errors was no longer significant when Verbal IQ was partialled out. Executive functioning was strongly related to all IQ variables in the DLD group and particularly related to Verbal IQ in the HAD group. Although there was a relationship in the HAD group between executive functioning and adaptive functioning, as well as between executive functioning and autistic symptomatology, these relationships were generally no longer significant in the HAD group after the variance due to Verbal IQ was accounted for. The results are interpreted to indicate that although impaired executive functioning is a commonly associated feature of autism, it is not universal in autism and is unlikely to cause autistic behaviors or deficits in adaptive function.
对34名发育性语言障碍(DLD)儿童(24名男孩和10名女孩)和21名高功能自闭症障碍(HAD)儿童(18名男孩和3名女孩)的执行功能进行了研究,这些儿童在全量表智商、非言语智商、年龄(平均年龄9岁1个月)和社会经济地位方面进行了匹配。DLD组的言语智商比HAD组高10分。这些儿童接受了威斯康星卡片分类测试(WCST)、韦氏儿童智力量表修订版(WISC-R)中的迷宫子测试、下划线测试和快速自动命名测试。此外,还对这些儿童进行了文兰适应功能量表和温格诊断症状清单测试,以评估自闭症症状的严重程度。结果表明,两组在认知任务上的唯一显著差异是WCST上的持续性错误;在达到的类别总数、WCST上的错误总数或其他执行功能测量方面没有显著差异。两组的分数也有很大重叠,当排除言语智商的影响时,持续性错误的差异不再显著。在DLD组中,执行功能与所有智商变量密切相关,在HAD组中尤其与言语智商相关。虽然在HAD组中执行功能与适应功能之间以及执行功能与自闭症症状之间存在关系,但在排除言语智商的方差影响后,这些关系在HAD组中通常不再显著。研究结果表明,虽然执行功能受损是自闭症常见的相关特征,但它在自闭症中并不普遍,也不太可能导致自闭症行为或适应功能缺陷。