De Ponti F, Tonini M
Department of Pharmacology, University of Bologna, Italy.
Drugs. 2001;61(3):317-32. doi: 10.2165/00003495-200161030-00001.
Although the past few years have seen an exponential growth of compounds of potential interest for the treatment of functional gastrointestinal (GI) tract disorders, the gap that still exists between basic and clinical research is easily noticed if one considers the relative paucity of drugs that have received marketing authorisation for the treatment of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS). Traditional efficacy outcomes in drug development for IBS include the ability of the compound to affect GI tract motility (i.e. to exert a prokinetic or an antispasmodic effect), which is thought to be of importance if a motor disorder is the underlying pathophysiological mechanism. More recently, altered visceral sensitivity to a distending stimulus has been suggested to be a key pathophysiological feature, at least in some patients, and has become a target for therapeutic interventions. However, there is now growing consensus that the primary outcome measure in the treatment of functional disorders are those that reflect overall control of the patient's symptoms (pain, diarrhoea, constipation) in everyday situations such as the clinical global improvement scales. Although, in general, guidelines on the design of treatment trials for functional GI tract disorders advise against subcategorisation of patients according to the main symptom (because of symptom instability), subcategorisation indeed makes sense especially in IBS (constipation- or diarrhoea-predominant). Compounds with a specific indication for each subpopulation of patients are now emerging. The rationale for investigations on serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine; 5-HT) receptor ligands in IBS rests mainly on the fact that serotonin, which may be released by enterochromaffin-like cells in the GI tract as well as from other sources, has a number of well documented motor effects on the GI tract and can produce hyperalgesia in several experimental models. Serotonin receptors belonging to the 5-HT3 and 5-HT4 subtype are the most extensively studied in gastroenterology, although hitherto 'orphan' receptor subtypes, such as the 5-HT7 and the 5-HT(1B/D) receptors, are now emerging. Among 5-HT3 receptor antagonists, alosetron was recently approved for the treatment of diarrhoea-predominant IBS and is an example of a compound that, at least theoretically, may act at multiple levels: by inhibiting visceral sensitivity, by increasing compliance, and by inhibiting excitatory 5-HT3 receptors located on both ascending and descending neuronal pathways involved in peristalsis. For this reason, 5-HT3 receptor antagonists may slow transit, hence the specific indication of alosetron in diarrhoea-predominant IBS. However, alosetron has been recently withdrawn by the manufacturer because of safety concerns. Hypomotility remains an attractive therapeutic target in IBS and the new generation of prokinetics includes several partial agonists at the 5-HT4 receptor, such as tegaserod (HTF-919) and prucalopride (R0-93877). In addition, preliminary evidence suggests that 5-HT4 receptors may also be involved in the modulation of visceral sensitivity. Second-generation 5-HT4 receptor agonists seem to be devoid of the QT-prolonging effects observed in some clinical circumstances with cisapride and may be more active at the colonic level. Piboserod (SB-207266A) is a 5-HT4 receptor antagonist under development for the treatment of diarrhoea-predominant IBS. Finally, interest in 5-HT7 and 5-HT(1B/D) receptor subtypes stems from the observation that the former receptors mediate smooth muscle relaxation (at least in the human colon), whereas sumatriptan (a 5-HT(1B/D) receptor agonist) can affect GI tract motility and visceral sensitivity.
尽管在过去几年中,有望用于治疗功能性胃肠道(GI)疾病的化合物呈指数级增长,但如果考虑到已获得治疗肠易激综合征(IBS)上市许可的药物相对较少,基础研究与临床研究之间仍然存在的差距就很容易被注意到。IBS药物研发中的传统疗效指标包括化合物影响胃肠道动力的能力(即发挥促动力或解痉作用),如果运动障碍是潜在的病理生理机制,这被认为是很重要的。最近,有人提出内脏对扩张刺激的敏感性改变是至少部分患者的关键病理生理特征,并已成为治疗干预的靶点。然而,现在越来越多的人达成共识,即功能性疾病治疗的主要疗效指标是那些反映患者在日常情况下(如临床总体改善量表)症状(疼痛、腹泻、便秘)总体控制情况的指标。虽然一般来说,功能性胃肠道疾病治疗试验设计指南建议不要根据主要症状对患者进行亚分类(因为症状不稳定),但亚分类在IBS(以便秘或腹泻为主)中确实是有意义的。现在正在出现针对每个患者亚群有特定适应证的化合物。对IBS中5-羟色胺(5-羟色胺;5-HT)受体配体进行研究的基本原理主要基于这样一个事实,即5-羟色胺可由胃肠道中的肠嗜铬样细胞以及其他来源释放,它对胃肠道有许多已被充分证明的运动效应,并且在一些实验模型中可产生痛觉过敏。5-HT3和5-HT4亚型的5-羟色胺受体是胃肠病学中研究最广泛的,尽管迄今“孤儿”受体亚型,如5-HT7和5-HT(1B/D)受体,现在也开始出现。在5-HT3受体拮抗剂中,阿洛司琼最近被批准用于治疗以腹泻为主的IBS,并是一种至少在理论上可能在多个水平起作用的化合物的例子:通过抑制内脏敏感性、通过增加顺应性以及通过抑制位于参与蠕动的升、降神经元通路上的兴奋性5-HT3受体。因此,5-HT3受体拮抗剂可能会减慢转运,因此阿洛司琼在以腹泻为主的IBS中有特定适应证。然而,由于安全问题,阿洛司琼最近已被制造商撤回。动力不足仍然是IBS中一个有吸引力的治疗靶点,新一代促动力药包括几种5-HT4受体的部分激动剂,如替加色罗(HTF-919)和普芦卡必利(R0-93877)。此外,初步证据表明5-HT4受体也可能参与内脏敏感性的调节。第二代5-HT4受体激动剂似乎没有在某些临床情况下观察到的西沙必利引起的QT间期延长效应,并可能在结肠水平更具活性。匹莫色罗(SB-207266A)是一种正在研发用于治疗以腹泻为主的IBS的5-HT4受体拮抗剂。最后,对5-HT7和5-HT(1B/D)受体亚型的兴趣源于这样的观察,即前者受体介导平滑肌松弛(至少在人结肠中),而舒马曲坦(一种5-HT(1B/D)受体激动剂)可影响胃肠道动力和内脏敏感性。