Coid J, Kahtan N, Cook A, Gault S, Jarman B
Academic Section of Forensic Psychiatry, St Bartholomew's and the Royal London School of Medicine and Dentistry.
Psychol Med. 2001 Apr;31(3):531-9. doi: 10.1017/s003329170100366x.
The planning and development of secure forensic psychiatry services for mentally disordered offenders in England and Wales has proceeded independently within different regional areas. However, certain mental disorders, offenders, and offending behaviour are all more prevalent in geographical areas characterized by socio-economic deprivation and social disorganization. Failure to consider these factors has led to inadequate service provision in some areas and inequity in funding. A new model is required to predict admissions to these services as an aid to resource allocation.
Actual admissions (N = 3155) to high and medium secure psychiatric services for seven of 14 (pre-reorganization) Regional Health Authorities, 1988-94. Expected admissions were calculated for each district using 1991 census data adjusted for under-enumeration. Standardized psychiatric admission ratios were calculated and a range of social, health status, and service provision data were used as explanatory variables in a regression analysis to determine variation between districts.
Actual psychiatric admissions varied from 160% above to 62% below expected for age, sex, and marital status, according to patients' catchment area of origin, measured according to deciles of the distribution of underprivileged area scores at ward level. The most powerful explanatory variables included a composite measure of social deprivation, ethnicity and availability of low secure beds at regional level.
Admission rates to secure forensic psychiatry services demonstrate a linear correlation with measures of socio-economic deprivation in patients catchment area of origin. A model was developed to predict admissions from District Health Authorities and is recommended for future use in resource allocation. Identification of factors that explain higher admission rates of serious offenders with mental disorder from deprived areas is a priority for future research.
在英格兰和威尔士,为患有精神疾病的罪犯提供安全的法医精神病服务的规划和发展在不同区域内独立进行。然而,某些精神障碍、罪犯及犯罪行为在以社会经济贫困和社会混乱为特征的地理区域更为普遍。未能考虑这些因素导致一些地区服务提供不足以及资金分配不均。需要一种新模型来预测这些服务的入院人数,以辅助资源分配。
1988 - 1994年期间,对14个(重组前)区域卫生当局中的7个的高安全和中等安全精神病服务的实际入院人数(N = 3155)进行研究。使用针对人口漏计情况调整后的1991年人口普查数据为每个地区计算预期入院人数。计算标准化精神病入院率,并将一系列社会、健康状况和服务提供数据用作回归分析中的解释变量,以确定各地区之间的差异。
根据患者的原籍集水区,按病房层面贫困地区得分分布的十分位数衡量,实际精神病入院人数相对于年龄、性别和婚姻状况的预期人数,在高于预期160%至低于预期62%之间变化。最有力的解释变量包括社会剥夺的综合衡量指标、种族以及区域层面低安全床位的可获得性。
安全法医精神病服务的入院率与患者原籍集水区的社会经济剥夺指标呈线性相关。开发了一个模型来预测来自地区卫生当局的入院人数,建议在未来资源分配中使用。确定解释来自贫困地区患有精神疾病的严重罪犯较高入院率的因素是未来研究的重点。