Kalant H, LeBlanc A E, Wilson A, Homatidis S
Can Med Assoc J. 1975 Apr 19;112(8):953-8.
Effects of a standard dose of alcohol (1.3 g/kg) in the form of Canadian rye whisky, Canadian beer and a sparkling table wine were compared with those of a nonalcoholic carbonated control beverage. Sixteen young male and eight female subjects, all moderate drinkers, were tested in a Latin square design. Measurements were made on the pursuit rotor and quantitative Romberg tests, and of skin temperature, heart rate, malar flush and blood alcohol concentration during the prealcohol baseline period and at regular intervals over the 4-hour drinking period. The three alcoholic beverages produced blood alcohol curves that did not differ significantly. All three alcoholic beverages produced increasing sensorimotor impairment over time, which corresponded in degree to the increasing blood alcohol concentration. There were no significant differences between the three beverages on either the sensorimotor or physiological measures at any blood alcohol value. The results of this study indicate that the degree of impairment after alcohol ingestion in a socially relevant manner is not dependent on the type of beverage consumed, but only on the resulting blood alcohol concentration.
将加拿大黑麦威士忌、加拿大啤酒和起泡餐酒形式的标准剂量酒精(1.3克/千克)的效果与不含酒精的碳酸对照饮料的效果进行了比较。16名年轻男性和8名女性受试者,均为适度饮酒者,采用拉丁方设计进行测试。在饮酒前的基线期以及4小时饮酒期间定期测量追踪转子和定量罗姆伯格试验,以及皮肤温度、心率、脸颊潮红和血液酒精浓度。三种酒精饮料产生的血液酒精曲线没有显著差异。所有三种酒精饮料随着时间的推移都会产生越来越严重的感觉运动障碍,其程度与血液酒精浓度的增加相对应。在任何血液酒精值下,三种饮料在感觉运动或生理指标上均无显著差异。这项研究的结果表明,以与社交相关的方式摄入酒精后的损伤程度不取决于所饮用饮料的类型,而仅取决于所产生的血液酒精浓度。