Ferreira Sionaldo Eduardo, de Mello Marco Túlio, Pompéia Sabine, de Souza-Formigoni Maria Lucia Oliveira
Department of Psychobiology, Federal University of Sao Paulo (UNIFESP), the FAPESP fellowship, São Paulo-SP, Brasil.
Alcohol Clin Exp Res. 2006 Apr;30(4):598-605. doi: 10.1111/j.1530-0277.2006.00070.x.
Well-known reports suggest that the use of energy drinks might reduce the intensity of the depressant effects of alcohol. However, there is little scientific evidence to support this hypothesis.
The present study aimed at evaluating the effects of the simultaneous ingestion of an alcohol (vodka(37.5%v/v)) and an energy drink (Red Bull-3.57 mL/kg), compared with those presented after the ingestion of an alcohol or an energy drink alone. Twenty-six young healthy volunteers were randomly assigned to 2 groups that received 0.6 or 1.0 g/kg alcohol, respectively. They all completed 3 experimental sessions in random order, 7 days apart: alcohol alone, energy drink alone, or alcohol plus energy drink. We evaluated the volunteers' breath alcohol concentration, subjective sensations of intoxication, objective effects on their motor coordination, and visual reaction time.
When compared with the ingestion of alcohol alone, the ingestion of alcohol plus energy drink significantly reduced subjects' perception of headache, weakness, dry mouth, and impairment of motor coordination. However, the ingestion of the energy drink did not significantly reduce the deficits caused by alcohol on objective motor coordination and visual reaction time. The ingestion of the energy drink did not alter the breath alcohol concentration in either group.
Even though the subjective perceptions of some symptoms of alcohol intoxication were less intense after the combined ingestion of the alcohol plus energy drink, these effects were not detected in objective measures of motor coordination and visual reaction time, as well as on the breath alcohol concentration.
著名报告表明,饮用能量饮料可能会降低酒精的抑制作用强度。然而,几乎没有科学证据支持这一假设。
本研究旨在评估同时摄入酒精(伏特加,体积分数37.5%)和能量饮料(红牛,3.57 mL/kg)的效果,并与单独摄入酒精或能量饮料后的效果进行比较。26名年轻健康志愿者被随机分为两组,分别摄入0.6或1.0 g/kg酒精。他们均以随机顺序完成3次实验,每次间隔7天:单独饮酒、单独饮用能量饮料或酒精加能量饮料。我们评估了志愿者的呼气酒精浓度、醉酒的主观感受、对其运动协调性的客观影响以及视觉反应时间。
与单独饮酒相比,酒精加能量饮料显著降低了受试者对头痛、虚弱、口干和运动协调性受损的感知。然而,饮用能量饮料并未显著减轻酒精对客观运动协调性和视觉反应时间造成的缺陷。饮用能量饮料未改变两组的呼气酒精浓度。
尽管同时摄入酒精和能量饮料后,对酒精中毒某些症状的主观感受不那么强烈,但在运动协调性和视觉反应时间的客观测量以及呼气酒精浓度方面未发现这些效果。