Gjerberg E
Work Research Institute, Oslo, Norway.
Soc Sci Med. 2001 Feb;52(3):331-43. doi: 10.1016/s0277-9536(00)00138-6.
In Norway, as in most Western countries, doctors' choice of specialty has been strongly gendered. Female physicians have tended both to specialise to a lesser degree and to enter other specialties than male colleagues. In spite of the increase of women in medicine, previous studies have not managed to show any changes in this pattern. Comparing data from two cohorts of Norwegian doctors, authorised in 1970-73 and 1980-83 respectively, this article demonstrates that changes are in fact taking place. The changes are, however, not unequivocal. Firstly, women in these cohorts specialise to a very high degree and just as much as their male colleagues. Secondly, women doctors of the 1980s cohort spread their choice of specialisation over more fields than their predecessors did. They have, for example, started to enter surgery, although still not as often as men. Thirdly, proportionally more doctors of the 1980s cohort than the 1970s cohort have chosen general practice as their main specialty, and this applies to both women and men. Fourthly, there are tendencies towards an increasing concentration of women in some disciplines such as obstetrics and gynaecology, as well as paediatrics. These changes in doctors' pattern of specialisation are discussed as consequences of socially shaped individual preferences, structural aspects of the Norwegian health system and the existence of gendered closure mechanisms within specific medical fields. Although the medical profession still appears as a gender differentiated community, the article gives a more dynamic and in some respects a more optimistic picture than earlier studies.
在挪威,与大多数西方国家一样,医生对专业的选择存在强烈的性别差异。女医生往往比男同事在专业上的专注程度更低,且选择进入其他专业领域。尽管医学界女性人数有所增加,但此前的研究未能显示出这种模式有任何变化。通过比较分别在1970 - 1973年和1980 - 1983年获得授权的两组挪威医生的数据,本文表明事实上正在发生变化。然而,这些变化并不明确。首先,这两组中的女性在专业上的专注程度非常高,与男同事一样。其次,20世纪80年代那组的女医生在专业选择上比她们的前辈分布在更多领域。例如,她们已经开始进入外科领域,尽管人数仍不如男性。第三,按比例而言,20世纪80年代那组选择全科医学作为主要专业的医生比70年代那组更多,这在女性和男性中都适用。第四,有迹象表明女性在某些学科(如妇产科和儿科)中的集中度在增加。医生专业选择模式的这些变化被讨论为社会塑造的个人偏好、挪威卫生系统的结构方面以及特定医学领域内存在的性别封闭机制的结果。尽管医学界仍然呈现出一个性别分化的群体,但本文给出了一幅比早期研究更具动态性且在某些方面更乐观的图景。