Vanna A T, Yamada E, Arruda L K, Naspitz C K, Solé D
Division of Allergy, Clinical Immunology and Rheumatology, Department of Pediatrics, Universidade Federal de São Paulo, Escola Paulista de Medicina (UNIFESP-EPM), São Paulo, SP, Brazil.
Pediatr Allergy Immunol. 2001 Apr;12(2):95-101. doi: 10.1034/j.1399-3038.2001.012002095.x.
Written questionnaires (WQ) have been widely used in epidemiologic studies. In order to yield comparable results, they must be validated after translation to another language. The International Study of Asthma and Allergies in Childhood (ISAAC) WQ has been previously validated by a comprehensive study, but its validation in Brazil has not been performed. Our objectives were to validate the rhinitis component of the ISAAC's self-applicable WQ following its translation to Portuguese, and to determine the prevalence of rhinitis and related symptoms among Brazilian children living in the city of São Paulo. A group of 10 pediatricians and 10 pediatric allergists graded the questions from 0 to 2 and established a maximum score for each question. The WQ was answered by parents or guardians of children 6-7 years of age with rhinitis (R) (n = 27) and of control children of the same age without rhinitis (C) (n = 27). The WQ was also completed by adolescents 13-14 years of age with rhinitis (R) (n = 32) and without rhinitis (C) (n = 32). Half of these individuals answered the same WQ after 2-4 weeks, to ensure reproducibility. Cut-off scores of 4 and 3 were identified for the 6-7- and 13-14-year-old groups, respectively, as scores predictive of rhinitis. The prevalence of rhinitis was 28.8% in the group of 3005 children 6-7 years of age and 31.7% in the group of 3008 children 13-14 years of age, respectively. Using the global cut-off score, these prevalences were even higher, in the order of 34.7% and 40.7%, respectively. In conclusion, the rhinitis component of the ISAAC WQ was proven to be reproducible, adequate and able to discriminate children and adolescents with and without rhinitis, and revealed that the prevalence of rhinitis among Brazilian children living in the city of São Paulo was as high as the prevalence of rhinitis in other areas of the world.
书面问卷(WQ)已广泛应用于流行病学研究。为了得出可比的结果,问卷在翻译成另一种语言后必须经过验证。儿童哮喘和过敏国际研究(ISAAC)问卷先前已通过一项全面研究得到验证,但在巴西尚未进行验证。我们的目标是在将ISAAC的自填式问卷翻译成葡萄牙语后,验证其鼻炎部分,并确定居住在圣保罗市的巴西儿童中鼻炎及相关症状的患病率。一组10名儿科医生和10名儿科过敏症专科医生对问题从0到2进行评分,并为每个问题确定最高分。问卷由6 - 7岁患有鼻炎(R)的儿童(n = 27)和同龄无鼻炎的对照儿童(C)(n = 27)的父母或监护人回答。问卷也由13 - 14岁患有鼻炎(R)(n = 32)和无鼻炎(C)(n = 32)的青少年完成。其中一半个体在2 - 4周后回答相同问卷,以确保可重复性。分别确定6 - 7岁和13 - 14岁组的临界分数为4分和3分,作为鼻炎的预测分数。在年龄为6 - 7岁的3005名儿童组中鼻炎患病率为28.8%,在年龄为13 - 14岁的3008名儿童组中为31.7%。使用总体临界分数,这些患病率更高,分别约为34.7%和40.7%。总之,ISAAC问卷的鼻炎部分被证明具有可重复性、适当性,能够区分患有和未患鼻炎的儿童及青少年,并且显示居住在圣保罗市的巴西儿童中鼻炎患病率与世界其他地区一样高。