Morgan R, Tsang J, Harrington N, Fook L
Arrowe Park Hospital, Upton, Wirral, Merseyside L69 5PE, UK.
Postgrad Med J. 2001 Jun;77(908):392-4. doi: 10.1136/pmj.77.908.392.
The study was designed to assess the views and knowledge of hospital doctors in general and geriatric medicine on oral health in older people. Eighty two doctors in general and geriatric medicine at two hospitals were shown 12 colour slides of oral mucosal conditions and asked to give a diagnosis for each slide and complete a questionnaire. Completed questionnaires with the answers to the coloured slides were returned completed by 70 doctors. The majority of doctors (84%) felt it was important to examine older patients' mouths, however only 19% (chi(2) p=0.0001) routinely do so. If asked to prescribe nystatin by the nursing staff, 30% said they would do so without examining the mouth itself. Only 9% of doctors knew that wearing dentures was a specific risk factor for oral candidiasis (chi(2) p=0.001). Altogether 56% of doctors did not feel confident in examining the oral cavity and most (77%) did not think they had had sufficient training in this examination. Only two doctors correctly diagnosed all of the slides. An early squamous carcinoma was misdiagnosed by 80% of the doctors (chi(2) p=0.0001). Hospital doctors do not routinely inspect older patients' mouths. Even if shown slides of typical oral mucosal lesions many hospital doctors are unable to diagnose them. Issues on training need to be addressed. From the patients' point of view a public health campaign is required to educate older people on the need for a regular dental review and be aware that doctors may not be able to diagnose serious oral conditions.
该研究旨在评估普通内科和老年医学科医院医生对老年人口腔健康的看法和知识。向两家医院的82名普通内科和老年医学科医生展示了12张口腔黏膜状况的彩色幻灯片,并要求他们对每张幻灯片进行诊断并完成一份问卷。70名医生返还了填写完整的问卷及对彩色幻灯片的答案。大多数医生(84%)认为检查老年患者的口腔很重要,然而只有19%的医生(卡方检验p = 0.0001)会定期这样做。如果护士要求开具制霉菌素,30%的医生表示他们会在不检查口腔本身的情况下开具。只有9%的医生知道佩戴假牙是口腔念珠菌病的一个特定风险因素(卡方检验p = 0.001)。总共有56%的医生对检查口腔没有信心,大多数医生(77%)认为他们在这项检查方面没有接受过足够的培训。只有两名医生正确诊断了所有幻灯片。80%的医生误诊了一例早期鳞状细胞癌(卡方检验p = 0.0001)。医院医生不会定期检查老年患者的口腔。即使向他们展示典型口腔黏膜病变的幻灯片,许多医院医生也无法诊断。培训问题需要得到解决。从患者的角度来看,需要开展一场公共卫生运动,教育老年人定期进行牙齿检查的必要性,并让他们意识到医生可能无法诊断严重的口腔疾病。