Johnson D G, Smith V C, Tarnoff S L
J Med Educ. 1975 Jul;50(7):713-55. doi: 10.1097/00001888-197507000-00015.
This is a report on a national study of minority group applicants and entrants to the 1970, 1971, and 1972 entering classes of U.S. medical colleges. The aim of the investigation was to further understanding of the factors involved in attempting to increase minority representation in education for the practice of medicine. Data from the Association of American Medical Colleges are used to examine characteristics of successful and unsuccessful minority applicants to medical school. Socieconomic, personal, institutiona, and geographical factors that relate to the recruitment and progress of minority students in medicine are analyzed and evaluated. Differences between Caucasian and minority group students affecting admissions, retention, and promotion are documented. The investigators also compare the projections of a 1970 AAMC task force report with actual occurrences in the national effort to expand educational opportunities in medicine for blacks and other underrepresented minority students (that is, American Indians, Mexican Americans, and mainland Puerto Ricans). This comparison shows substantial progress toward the projected figures but a need for renewed commitment if they are to be reached. Suggestions are offered for improving the recruitment and progress of minority medical school entrants by such means as the AAMC Simulated Minority Admissions Exercises and by ongoing programs at individual medical schools. The study also yielded such pertinent findings as the following: 1. Confirmation that the racial characterizations self-reported by medical school applicants have a high degree of accuracy and an increasing degree of completeness. 2. An encouraging increase in the number of black premedical students who will potentially apply for the medical school classes entering in 1976 and 1977. 3. Growth in the enrollment of low-income medical students, most of it explained by the increase in the numbers of minority group members who have been admitted in recent years. 4. More mobility among blacks than Caucasians with regard to attending medical schools in other than their region of legal residence. 5. A higher proportion of women, of older, and of married students among minority medical school matriculants than among Caucasian matriculants. 6. A slightly higher medical school retention rate for Caucasians than for students from underrepresented minority groups, possibly explained in part by the greater diversity in the socioeconomic and educational backgrounds of the latter. 7. A positive relationship for blacks between the size of undergraduate college attended and successful completion of the first year of medical school.
这是一份关于对1970年、1971年和1972年进入美国医学院班级的少数群体申请者和入学学生进行的全国性研究报告。该调查的目的是进一步了解在试图增加医学教育中少数群体代表性所涉及的因素。美国医学院协会的数据被用于研究成功和不成功的医学院少数群体申请者的特征。分析和评估了与少数群体学生在医学领域的招生和进步相关的社会经济、个人、机构和地理因素。记录了影响录取、留校和晋升的白种学生和少数群体学生之间的差异。研究人员还将1970年美国医学院协会特别工作组报告中的预测与全国为黑人及其他代表性不足的少数群体学生(即美国印第安人、墨西哥裔美国人及波多黎各本土人)扩大医学教育机会的实际情况进行了比较。这种比较表明朝着预测数字取得了重大进展,但如果要实现这些数字仍需要重新做出承诺。报告提出了一些建议,如通过美国医学院协会模拟少数群体录取练习以及各医学院正在开展的项目等方式,来改善少数群体医学院入学学生的招生和进步情况。该研究还得出了以下相关发现:1. 证实医学院申请者自我报告的种族特征具有高度准确性且完整性程度不断提高。2. 有望申请1976年和1977年医学院班级的黑人医学预科学生数量令人鼓舞地增加。3. 低收入医学生的入学人数有所增长,这主要是由于近年来录取的少数群体成员数量增加。4. 与白种人相比,黑人在其法定居住地区以外就读医学院校方面的流动性更大。5. 少数群体医学院录取学生中女性、年龄较大者和已婚学生的比例高于白种录取学生。6. 白种学生的医学院留校率略高于代表性不足的少数群体学生,部分原因可能是后者的社会经济和教育背景更加多样化。7. 对于黑人来说,所就读本科院校的规模与医学院第一年的顺利完成之间存在正相关关系。