Thevenot C, Barrouillet P, Fayol M
Université de Bourgogne, LEAD-CNRS, Faculté des Sciences Gabriel, 6 Bld Gabriel, 21000 Dijon, France.
Q J Exp Psychol A. 2001 May;54(2):599-611. doi: 10.1080/713755966.
Many developmental models of arithmetic problem solving assume that any algorithmic solution of a given problem results in an association of the two operands and the answer in memory (Logan & Klapp, 1991; Siegler, 1996). In this experiment, adults had to perform either an operation or a comparison on the same pairs of two-digit numbers and then a recognition task. It is shown that unlike comparisons, the algorithmic solution of operations impairs the recognition of operands in adults. Thus, the postulate of a necessary and automatic storage of operands-answer associations in memory when young children solve additions by algorithmic strategies needs to be qualified.
许多算术问题解决的发展模型都假定,给定问题的任何算法解决方案都会在记忆中形成两个操作数与答案之间的关联(洛根和克拉普,1991;西格勒,1996)。在本实验中,成年人必须对相同的两位数对执行运算或比较,然后进行识别任务。结果表明,与比较不同,运算的算法解决方案会损害成年人对操作数的识别。因此,当幼儿通过算法策略解决加法问题时,关于操作数 - 答案关联在记忆中必然且自动存储的假设需要修正。