Wasserfallen J B
Centre hospitalier universitaire vaudois.
Rev Med Suisse Romande. 2001 Apr;121(4):265-8.
After an extraordinary technical development, medicine is under close scrutiny and requested to prove that its diagnostic and therapeutic procedures are "efficient, appropriate, and economical". Evidence based medicine allows the optimal use of existing data in the literature, but focuses only on health care benefits. Economical analyses take into account the health care resources needed to get these benefits. The various types of costs, perspectives of analysis, and techniques for assessing benefits and uncertainty about cost estimates, are presented and illustrated with two examples drawn from the fields of primary care and advanced technology. Because the cost benefit ratio of a diagnostic or therapeutic procedure is heavily dependent on the type of patients to which it is applied, as well as on the stage of technological progress, the two types of information are necessary to fully assess medical procedures.
经过非凡的技术发展后,医学正受到密切审视,并被要求证明其诊断和治疗程序是“有效、恰当且经济的”。循证医学能让现有文献数据得到最优利用,但仅关注医疗保健效益。经济分析则会考虑获得这些效益所需的医疗保健资源。本文介绍了各类成本、分析视角以及评估效益的技术和成本估算的不确定性,并通过初级保健和先进技术领域的两个例子加以说明。由于诊断或治疗程序的成本效益比很大程度上取决于应用该程序的患者类型以及技术进步阶段,所以这两类信息对于全面评估医疗程序是必要的。