Bhandari N, Bahl R, Nayyar B, Khokhar P, Rohde J E, Bhan M K
Department of Pediatrics, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, Ansari Nagar, New Delhi, 110029, India.
J Nutr. 2001 Jul;131(7):1946-51. doi: 10.1093/jn/131.7.1946.
It is unclear whether a substantial decline in malnutrition among infants in developing countries can be achieved by increasing food availability and nutrition counseling without concurrent morbidity-reducing interventions. The study was designed to determine whether provision of generous amounts of a micronutrient-fortified food supplement supported by counseling or nutritional counseling alone would significantly improve physical growth between 4 and 12 mo of age. In a controlled trial, 418 infants 4 mo of age were individually randomized to one of the four groups and followed until 12 mo of age. The first group received a milk-based cereal and nutritional counseling; the second group monthly nutritional counseling alone. To control for the effect of twice-weekly home visits for morbidity ascertainment, similar visits were made in one of the control groups (visitation group); the fourth group received no intervention. The median energy intake from nonbreast milk sources was higher in the food supplementation group than in the visitation group by 1212 kJ at 26 wk (P < 0.001), 1739 kJ at 38 wk (P < 0.001) and 2257 kJ at 52 wk (P < 0.001). The food supplementation infants gained 250 g (95% confidence interval: 20--480 g) more weight than did the visitation group. The difference in the mean increment in length during the study was 0.4 cm (95% confidence interval: -0.1--0.9 cm). The nutritional counseling group had higher energy intakes ranging from 280 to 752 kJ at different ages (P < 0.05 at all ages) but no significant benefit on weight and length increments. Methods to enhance the impact of these interventions need to be identified.
在没有同时进行降低发病率干预措施的情况下,仅通过增加食物供应和营养咨询,是否能够大幅降低发展中国家婴儿的营养不良状况尚不清楚。本研究旨在确定提供大量的微量营养素强化食品补充剂并辅以咨询服务,或者仅提供营养咨询服务,是否能显著改善4至12月龄婴儿的身体生长情况。在一项对照试验中,418名4月龄婴儿被分别随机分配到四个组之一,并随访至12月龄。第一组接受以牛奶为基础的谷物食品和营养咨询;第二组仅接受每月一次的营养咨询。为了控制每周两次的家访对发病率测定的影响,在其中一个对照组(家访组)进行了类似的家访;第四组不接受任何干预。在26周时,食物补充组非母乳来源的能量摄入中位数比家访组高1212千焦(P<0.001),在38周时高1739千焦(P<0.001),在52周时高2257千焦(P<0.001)。接受食物补充的婴儿比家访组婴儿体重多增加250克(95%置信区间:20-480克)。研究期间平均身长增加的差异为0.4厘米(95%置信区间:-0.1-至0.9厘米)。营养咨询组在不同年龄的能量摄入量较高,范围为280至752千焦(所有年龄P<0.05),但对体重和身长增加没有显著益处。需要确定增强这些干预措施效果的方法。