Ntziachristos V, Chance B
Departments of Bioengineering, Biochemistry/Biophysics, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19104-6089,
Med Phys. 2001 Jun;28(6):1115-24. doi: 10.1118/1.1373674.
We assess typical systematic experimental errors involved in a time-resolved measurement as applied to NIR diffuse optical spectroscopy and investigate their effect on the quantification accuracy of the absorption and the reduced scattering coefficient. We demonstrate that common systematic experimental uncertainties may lead to quantification errors of 10% or more, even when excellent signal to noise ratio conditions exist and accurate photon propagation models are employed. We further demonstrate that the accuracy of the calculation depends nonlinearly on the optical properties of the medium measured. High scattering and low absorbing media can be quantified more accurately than media with low scattering or high absorption using measurements of the same signal to noise ratio. We further discuss curve-shape fitting schemes that aid in improving the quantification accuracy in the presence of experimental errors. Finally, we identify uncertainties that set quantification accuracy limits and we find temporal resolution as the ultimate limiting factor in the quantification accuracy achieved. Our findings suggest that temporal resolution of the order of 10 ps is necessary for quantifying the absorption and reduced scattering coefficient of diffuse media with accuracy better than 5% using curve fitting methods. In that sense this analysis can be used in time-resolved system design and in predicting the expected errors given the technology selected for time-resolved measurements.
我们评估了应用于近红外漫射光学光谱的时间分辨测量中涉及的典型系统实验误差,并研究了它们对吸收和约化散射系数定量精度的影响。我们证明,即使在信噪比极佳的条件下且使用了精确的光子传播模型,常见的系统实验不确定性仍可能导致10%或更高的定量误差。我们进一步证明,计算精度非线性地取决于所测量介质的光学特性。在相同信噪比测量条件下,高散射和低吸收介质比低散射或高吸收介质能够被更精确地定量。我们还讨论了有助于在存在实验误差的情况下提高定量精度的曲线形状拟合方案。最后,我们确定了设定定量精度极限的不确定性因素,并发现时间分辨率是实现的定量精度的最终限制因素。我们的研究结果表明,使用曲线拟合方法以优于5%的精度定量漫射介质的吸收和约化散射系数时,10皮秒量级的时间分辨率是必要的。从这个意义上说,该分析可用于时间分辨系统设计,并在给定用于时间分辨测量的技术时预测预期误差。