Bartolomeo P, Chokron S, Gainotti G
INSERM Unit 324, Centre Paul Broca 2ter rue d'Alésia, F-75014 Paris, France.
Neuropsychologia. 2001;39(10):1013-21. doi: 10.1016/s0028-3932(01)00042-2.
Signs of unilateral neglect for events occurring in one hemispace most often result from right hemisphere lesions. Right unilateral neglect after left hemisphere damage is much rarer, and has received less attention. The present study explores the relationships between right unilateral neglect and asymmetries in producing laterally directed arm movements in the horizontal plane in left brain-damaged (LBD) patients. Participants produced right- or left-directed arm movements with their left arm in response to centrally located visual stimuli. Results showed that LBD patients with signs of right unilateral neglect were consistently slowed when producing arm movements toward the right (neglected) side, as compared to left-directed movements. Taking into account patients with and without signs of neglect, this directional asymmetry positively correlated with a reaction-time measure of perceptual spatial bias. These findings stand in contrast with previous results obtained with the same experimental paradigm in right brain-damaged patients, in whom a consistent slowing of leftward-directed movements was rare and apparently unrelated to the presence and severity of left neglect. These conflicting results are discussed with respect to the hypothesis that different mechanisms may underlie left and right unilateral neglect.
对发生在一个半空间的事件出现单侧忽视的迹象,最常见于右脑损伤。左脑损伤后出现右侧单侧忽视的情况则要罕见得多,且受到的关注较少。本研究探讨了右脑损伤(LBD)患者右侧单侧忽视与在水平面产生侧向手臂运动时的不对称性之间的关系。参与者根据位于中央的视觉刺激,用左臂做出向右或向左的手臂运动。结果显示,有右侧单侧忽视迹象的LBD患者在将手臂移向右侧(被忽视)时,与向左运动相比,动作始终较慢。综合考虑有或没有忽视迹象的患者,这种方向不对称与感知空间偏差的反应时间测量呈正相关。这些发现与之前在右脑损伤患者中使用相同实验范式得到的结果形成对比,在右脑损伤患者中,向左运动持续减慢的情况很少见,且显然与左侧忽视的存在和严重程度无关。针对不同机制可能是左右单侧忽视的基础这一假设,对这些相互矛盾的结果进行了讨论。