Lesmes-Anel J, Robinson G, Moody S
Br J Gen Pract. 2001 Jul;51(468):559-64.
Experienced trainers know that individual registrars react very differently to identical learning experiences generated during the year in practice. This divergence reflects differences in registrars' learning styles. Only one study of United Kingdom (UK) general practitioners' learning styles has been undertaken. Learning style theory predicts that matching learning preference with learning style will enhance learning. This paper researches for the first time the evidence in the setting of UK general practice.
To determine, for the general practice registrars within the Wessex Region, the nature of their learning preferences and learning styles and correlations between them.
A descriptive confidential postal questionnaire survey.
Fifty-seven registrars identified in the Wessex Region with a minimum experience of six months in general practice.
The questionnaire gathered demographic data (sex, age, experience in general practice, years post-registration, and postgraduate qualifications). Learning preferences were elicited using a six-point Likert scale for learning experiences. The Honey and Mumford Learning Style Questionnaire (LSQ) elicited the registrars' learning styles. A second questionnaire was sent to non-responders.
The response rate was 74%. Registrars report that interactive learning with feedback is preferred, but more passive learning formats remain valued. A wide range of learning style scores was found. The Honey and Mumford LSQ mean scores fell within the reflector-theorist quadrant. Evidence for correlations between learning preferences and learning styles was also found, in particular for the multiple choice question and audit components of summative assessment.
A wide range of registrar learning styles exists in Wessex, and initial correlations are described between learning preferences and learning styles as predicted by style theory. This work sets the stage for a shared understanding and use of learning style theory to enhance professional learning throughout a GP's career. More research is needed in this domain.
经验丰富的培训师知道,在一年的实习期间,即使面对相同的学习经历,不同的住院医生的反应也大不相同。这种差异反映了住院医生学习风格的不同。目前仅开展过一项针对英国全科医生学习风格的研究。学习风格理论预测,将学习偏好与学习风格相匹配会提高学习效果。本文首次在英国全科医疗的背景下对此证据进行研究。
确定韦塞克斯地区全科医疗住院医生的学习偏好和学习风格的本质以及二者之间的相关性。
一项描述性保密邮寄问卷调查。
在韦塞克斯地区确定的57名住院医生,他们至少有6个月的全科医疗实习经验。
问卷收集了人口统计学数据(性别、年龄、全科医疗经验、注册后年限和研究生学历)。使用六点李克特量表来了解学习经历方面的学习偏好。通过 Honey and Mumford 学习风格问卷(LSQ)来确定住院医生的学习风格。向未回复者发送了第二份问卷。
回复率为74%。住院医生报告说,他们更喜欢有反馈的互动式学习,但更多被动的学习形式也仍然受到重视。发现了广泛的学习风格得分。Honey and Mumford LSQ 的平均得分落在反思型 - 理论型象限内。还发现了学习偏好与学习风格之间存在相关性的证据,特别是在总结性评估的多项选择题和审核部分。
韦塞克斯地区存在广泛的住院医生学习风格,并且如风格理论所预测的那样,初步描述了学习偏好与学习风格之间的相关性。这项工作为共同理解和运用学习风格理论以促进全科医生整个职业生涯中的专业学习奠定了基础。该领域还需要更多研究。