Brodie M J, Kwan P
University Department of Medicine and Therapeutics, Western Infirmary, Glasgow, Scotland.
CNS Drugs. 2001 Jan;15(1):1-12; discussion 13-5. doi: 10.2165/00023210-200115010-00001.
An explosion in antiepileptic drug (AED) therapy began in the 1990s with the licensing of 9 new chemical entities and more to come. Important differences between AEDs may not be detected by regulatory trials, which are designed to satisfy licensing requirements and often diverge considerably from everyday clinical practice. The Star Systems have been developed as evidence-based yet pragmatic and flexible models for comparing AEDs. Each drug has been judged across a range of criteria, including mechanism of action, pharmacokinetics, ease of use, efficacy, tolerability, safety, interaction profile and a 'comfort factor'. A score has been allocated under each category and systems have been devised for patients with newly diagnosed epilepsy and those with difficult-to-control seizures requiring combination therapy. The choice of treatment should involve assessment of patient-related factors, accurate classification of seizure type and syndrome, married with an understanding of the pharmacology of the AEDs. A staged management plan should be formulated when initiating treatment with the aim of preventing the development of refractory epilepsy. When using combinations of AEDs, the mechanism of action of each agent should be taken into consideration. Such an individualised approach to management will optimise the chance of attaining remission and help many more patients achieve a fulfilling life.
20世纪90年代,随着9种新化学实体抗癫痫药物(AED)的获批上市以及更多药物即将问世,AED治疗领域出现了爆发式增长。监管试验可能无法检测出AED之间的重要差异,这些试验旨在满足获批要求,且往往与日常临床实践有很大差异。“星级系统”已被开发出来,作为比较AED的基于证据且实用灵活的模型。每种药物都根据一系列标准进行了评判,包括作用机制、药代动力学、易用性、疗效、耐受性、安全性、相互作用情况以及“舒适因子”。在每个类别下都给出了一个分数,并针对新诊断的癫痫患者以及需要联合治疗的难治性癫痫患者设计了相应系统。治疗选择应包括对患者相关因素的评估、癫痫发作类型和综合征的准确分类,并结合对AED药理学的了解。开始治疗时应制定一个分阶段管理计划,以防止难治性癫痫的发展。使用AED联合用药时,应考虑每种药物的作用机制。这种个体化的管理方法将优化实现缓解的机会,并帮助更多患者过上充实的生活。