Shang Z
Zhonghua Yi Shi Za Zhi. 1996;26(1):54-5.
It is generally believed that Ziyi Bencao is a book of the pre-Qin period. By studies on several aspects, including ancient bibliographical records, relics unearthed in Mawangdui Han tombs, nomenclature of ancient book titles, the date of appearance of ancient classics, contradictions between the time of activities of Bian Que and Ziyi, it is concluded that, in the pre-Qin period, there were no classic of herbology of any kind, even less Ziyi Bencao. The books entitled Ziyi Bencao recorded in bibliographies after Han Dynasty are all apocryphas made by Han authors.
人们普遍认为《紫仪本草》是先秦时期的一部书籍。通过对古代书目记载、马王堆汉墓出土文物、古籍书名命名、古代经典出现时间、扁鹊与紫仪活动时间矛盾等多个方面的研究,得出结论:先秦时期不存在任何种类的本草学经典,更不存在《紫仪本草》。汉代以后书目记载的名为《紫仪本草》的书籍都是汉代作者伪造的伪书。