Johnsen J, Bratt B M, Michel-Barron O, Glennow C, Petruson B
Department of Otorhinolaryngology, County Hospital, Skellefteå, Sweden.
Arch Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2001 Nov;127(11):1353-6. doi: 10.1001/archotol.127.11.1353.
To evaluate whether there was any difference in efficacy when nasal mucosa dryness was treated with pure sesame oil (Nozoil) compared with isotonic sodium chloride solution (ISCS).
In a randomized, crossover study, 79 subjects with nasal mucosa dryness were enrolled. Half the subjects received pure sesame oil for 14 days followed by ISCS for 14 days, and the other half received ISCS for 14 days followed by pure sesame oil for 14 days. During the test period from March 13 to May 30, 2000, the outdoor absolute humidity was low. Nasal mucosa dryness, stuffiness, and crusts were scored every evening with a visual analog scale.
The County Hospital, Skellefteå, Sweden.
Nasal mucosa dryness improved significantly when pure sesame oil was used compared with ISCS (P<.001). The improvement in nasal stuffiness was also better with pure sesame oil (P<.001) as was improvement in nasal crusts (P<.001). Eight of 10 subjects reported that their nasal symptoms had improved with pure sesame oil compared with 3 of 10 for ISCS (P<.001). Adverse events were few and temporary.
When nasal mucosa dryness due to a dry winter climate was treated, pure sesame oil was shown statistically to be significantly more effective than ISCS.
评估与等渗氯化钠溶液(ISCS)相比,用纯芝麻油(Nozoil)治疗鼻黏膜干燥时在疗效上是否存在差异。
在一项随机交叉研究中,纳入了79名鼻黏膜干燥的受试者。一半受试者先接受14天的纯芝麻油治疗,随后接受14天的ISCS治疗;另一半受试者先接受14天的ISCS治疗,随后接受14天的纯芝麻油治疗。在2000年3月13日至5月30日的测试期间,室外绝对湿度较低。每天晚上用视觉模拟量表对鼻黏膜干燥、鼻塞和鼻痂进行评分。
瑞典谢莱夫特奥县医院。
与ISCS相比,使用纯芝麻油时鼻黏膜干燥有显著改善(P<0.001)。纯芝麻油在改善鼻塞方面也更好(P<0.001),在改善鼻痂方面也是如此(P<0.001)。10名受试者中有8名报告称,与接受ISCS治疗的10名受试者中的3名相比,纯芝麻油使他们的鼻部症状得到了改善(P<0.001)。不良事件很少且为暂时性。
在治疗因冬季气候干燥导致的鼻黏膜干燥时,统计学显示纯芝麻油比ISCS显著更有效。