Sherman R C, End C, Kraan E, Cole A, Campbell J, Klausner J, Birchmeier Z
Department of Psychology, Miami University, Oxford, Ohio, USA.
Cyberpsychol Behav. 2001 Feb;4(1):123-9. doi: 10.1089/10949310151088497.
Knowing how others perceive us is an important aspect of social life. "Impression meta-accuracy" is the extent to which we are correct in our assumptions about the impressions others have formed of us. The goal of this study was to compare meta-accuracy of WWW homepage creators to meta-accuracy of people in face-to-face interactions. Because creators of WWW pages have a high degree of control over the information they make available online, they may believe that they accurately know the nature of the impressions they give to other people. However, perceivers of homepages must form impressions without many of the social and context cues that influence judgments in a face-to-face setting, including body language and speaking qualities, and thus their impressions may not match those assumed by the creators of the pages. Our results showed a general tendency for homepage creators to believe the impression they gave to those who viewed their pages was more positive than was actually the case, and this discrepancy was greater than in face-to-face interactions. The source of online inaccuracy seems to lie in people's belief that others develop the same impression of them in both online and offline contexts. In fact, perceivers are significantly influenced by whether the information they are receiving is based on face-to-face interaction or on cues obtained from a WWW homepage. Our data demonstrate that one of the challenges of social life in cyberspace is managing one's online persona to take into account the limitations of metaperception.
了解他人如何看待我们是社交生活的一个重要方面。“印象元准确性”指的是我们对他人对我们形成的印象的假设正确的程度。本研究的目的是比较万维网主页创建者的元准确性与面对面互动中人们的元准确性。由于网页创建者对他们在网上提供的信息有高度的控制权,他们可能认为自己准确地知道他们给其他人留下的印象的性质。然而,主页的观察者在形成印象时没有许多在面对面环境中影响判断的社会和情境线索,包括肢体语言和说话特质,因此他们的印象可能与网页创建者所设想的不匹配。我们的结果显示,主页创建者普遍倾向于认为他们给浏览其页面的人留下的印象比实际情况更积极,而且这种差异比面对面互动中更大。在线不准确的根源似乎在于人们相信其他人在在线和离线环境中对他们形成相同的印象。事实上,观察者会受到他们所接收的信息是基于面对面互动还是从万维网主页获得的线索的显著影响。我们的数据表明,网络空间社交生活的挑战之一是管理自己的网络形象,以考虑到元感知的局限性。