Jinabhai C C, Taylor M, Coutsoudis A, Coovadia H M, Tomkins A M, Sullivan K R
Department of Community Health, Nelson R. Mandela School of Medicine, University of Natal, Durban, South Africa.
Ann Trop Paediatr. 2001 Dec;21(4):319-33. doi: 10.1080/07430170120093508.
Single interventions for helminthic infections and micronutrient deficiencies are effective, but it is not clear whether combined interventions will provide equal, additive or synergistic effects to improve children's health. The study objective was to determine the impact of single and combined interventions on nutritional status and scholastic and cognitive performance of school children. A double-blind, randomized, placebo-controlled trial in 11 rural South African primary school randomly allocated 579 children aged between 8 and 10 years into six study groups, half of whom received antihelminthic treatment at baseline. The de-wormed and non-de-wormed arms were further divided into three groups and given biscuits, either unfortified or fortified with vitamin A and iron or with vitamin A only, given daily for 16 weeks. The outcome measures were anthropometric, micronutrient and parasite status, and scholastic and cognitive test scores. There was a significant treatment effect of vitamin A on serum retinol (p < 0.01), and the suggestion of an additive effect between vitamin A fortification and de-worming. Fortified biscuits improved micronutrient status in rural primary school children; vitamin A with de-worming had a greater impact on micronutrient status than vitamin A fortification alone and antihelminthic treatment significantly reduced the overall prevalence of parasite infection. The burden of micronutrient deficiency (anaemia, iron and vitamin A) and stunting in this study population was low and, coupled with the restricted duration of the intervention (16 weeks), might have limited the impact of the interventions.
针对蠕虫感染和微量营养素缺乏的单一干预措施是有效的,但联合干预措施是否能产生同等、相加或协同效应以改善儿童健康尚不清楚。本研究的目的是确定单一和联合干预措施对学童营养状况、学业和认知表现的影响。在南非农村的11所小学进行的一项双盲、随机、安慰剂对照试验,将579名8至10岁的儿童随机分为6个研究组,其中一半儿童在基线时接受抗蠕虫治疗。接受驱虫和未驱虫的组再进一步分为三组,分别给予未强化或强化了维生素A和铁或仅强化了维生素A的饼干,每天服用16周。观察指标包括人体测量、微量营养素和寄生虫状况,以及学业和认知测试成绩。维生素A对血清视黄醇有显著治疗效果(p < 0.01),并且有证据表明维生素A强化和驱虫之间存在相加效应。强化饼干改善了农村小学生的微量营养素状况;维生素A与驱虫联合使用对微量营养素状况的影响大于单独的维生素A强化,抗蠕虫治疗显著降低了寄生虫感染的总体患病率。本研究人群中微量营养素缺乏(贫血、铁和维生素A缺乏)和发育迟缓的负担较低,再加上干预时间有限(16周),可能限制了干预措施的效果。