Backe A
Department of History, Indiana University, USA.
Hist Psychol. 2001 Nov;4(4):323-40. doi: 10.1037/1093-4510.4.4.323.
John Dewey and James Angell are regarded respectively as the founder and systematizer of the Chicago school of functional psychology. The early Chicago school traditionally has been portrayed as a unified theoretical approach based primarily on William James's naturalist theory of mental processes. It is argued in this article that although the psychology systematized by Angell bore a close affinity to James's naturalism, Dewey's own psychology was based primarily on the neo-Hegelian philosophy of Thomas Hill Green. Through a review of a number of Dewey's major writings, Green's neo-Hegelian philosophy is shown to have influenced Dewey's views on psychological concepts such as reaction, emotion, and perception during the formative period of the Chicago school. The interpretation of Dewey's psychology developed in this article leads to the conclusion that early Chicago functionalism should not be regarded as a unified theoretical approach.
约翰·杜威和詹姆斯·安吉尔分别被视为芝加哥机能主义心理学派的创始人与集大成者。早期的芝加哥学派传统上被描绘为一种主要基于威廉·詹姆斯关于心理过程的自然主义理论的统一理论方法。本文认为,尽管安吉尔系统化的心理学与詹姆斯的自然主义密切相关,但杜威本人的心理学主要基于托马斯·希尔·格林的新黑格尔主义哲学。通过对杜威一些主要著作的回顾,新黑格尔主义哲学在芝加哥学派形成时期对杜威关于反应、情感和感知等心理学概念的观点产生了影响。本文对杜威心理学的解读得出结论:早期芝加哥机能主义不应被视为一种统一的理论方法。