Barbier D
Psychiatre des Hôpitaux, Centre Hospitalier, F84143 Montfavet.
Presse Med. 2001 Nov 24;30(35):1719-26.
BRIEF HISTORY: The definition of suicide differs depending on the era, author or theory. Society's attitude has varied throughout history. When psychiatry appeared in the nineteenth century it medicalized the problem. First with Esquirol in 1838, followed by Delmas in 1932. Whereas Durkheim, with his theory of anomia in 1897, defended the sociological position presented in the form of a law: the percentage of suicides increases in inverse proportion to the social integration of the individual and one should not forget Halbwachs (1930) in this debate. Re-medicalization was mainly due to Deshaies in 1947, who dismissed the excessiveness of these two trends, while remaining open to them. According to his theory, "suicidal equivalences" should also be taken into account, even if the individual's death wish is subconscious. CONTRIBUTION OF THE PSYCHOANALYTICAL THEORY: This contribution is considerable and has gone through several stages. Currently, psychoanalysts accept the influence of extrinsic factors in suicidal behavior. This is the case, for example, for the pre-morbid states or the initiating factors, the importance of which are no longer denied and which favor regression and destruction of the personality and resulting in suicidal behavior. DOES A CLINICAL PROFILE EXIST?: Fifteen percent of depressive patients commit suicide. With regard to the act itself, it is far more dangerous and violent in the elderly than in young adults. The suicide rate of elderly people is 2-fold greater than that of the general population. Suicidal equivalents consist in letting oneself die, because of the loss in will to fight that characterizes the classical syndrome of this attitude.
In France there are around 12,000 suicidal deaths per year among 150,000 suicide attempts, i.e., 1 attempt every 4 minutes and 1 suicide every 40 minutes. This corresponds to a raw mortality rate of 20 out of 100,000 inhabitants. However, epidemiologists consider that these figures are underestimated by around 20%. Since 1983, they exceed the mortality rate caused by road accidents (8,000/year in France). MISINTERPRETED DEPRESSION: Most suicides result from depression that was not recognized and treated as such. Clinical intuition is essential. It is the risk of suicide that renders the diagnosis of depression urgent. Retrospective surveys show that 50% of individuals having attempted suicide had consulted a doctor the month preceding their act. It is therefore important to organize the prevention of such risks. When depressive patients do not express any suicidal tendency, it is essential to raise the subject. In most cases, verbalization relieves the patients. However the eventual hospitalization of such patients should always be boum in mind.
简史:自杀的定义因时代、作者或理论而异。纵观历史,社会的态度各不相同。19世纪精神病学出现后,它将自杀问题医学化。先是1838年的埃斯基罗尔,接着是1932年的德尔马斯。而涂尔干在1897年提出失范理论,捍卫了以一种规律形式呈现的社会学观点:自杀率与个体的社会融合程度成反比,在这场辩论中不应忘记哈布瓦赫(1930年)。重新医学化主要归因于1947年的德谢耶,他摒弃了这两种趋势的极端之处,同时对它们持开放态度。根据他的理论,即使个体的死亡愿望是潜意识的,“自杀等同物”也应予以考虑。
这一贡献颇为显著且历经了几个阶段。目前,精神分析学家承认外在因素对自杀行为的影响。例如,病前状态或引发因素就是如此,其重要性已不再被否认,它们会促使人格退化和破坏,进而导致自杀行为。
是否存在临床特征?:15%的抑郁症患者会自杀。就自杀行为本身而言,老年人的自杀行为比年轻人更加危险和暴力。老年人的自杀率比普通人群高出两倍。自杀等同物表现为听任自己死亡,因为这种态度的典型综合征特征是失去抗争意志。
在法国,每年约有12000例自杀死亡,而自杀未遂达150000例次,即每4分钟有1次自杀未遂,每40分钟有1例自杀死亡。这相当于每10万居民中有20例的粗死亡率。然而,流行病学家认为这些数字被低估了约20%。自1983年以来,自杀死亡率超过了道路交通事故造成的死亡率(法国每年8000例)。
大多数自杀源于未被识别和治疗的抑郁症。临床直觉至关重要。正是自杀风险使得抑郁症的诊断刻不容缓。回顾性调查显示,50%的自杀未遂者在其自杀行为前一个月曾咨询过医生。因此,组织预防此类风险很重要。当抑郁症患者未表现出任何自杀倾向时,提出这个问题很有必要。在大多数情况下,倾诉能缓解患者的情绪。然而,始终要考虑对这类患者进行最终的住院治疗。