Gysin-Maillart Anja, Schwab Simon, Soravia Leila, Megert Millie, Michel Konrad
Outpatient Department, University Hospital of Psychiatry, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Translational Research Center, University Hospital of Psychiatry, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
PLoS Med. 2016 Mar 1;13(3):e1001968. doi: 10.1371/journal.pmed.1001968. eCollection 2016 Mar.
Attempted suicide is the main risk factor for suicide and repeated suicide attempts. However, the evidence for follow-up treatments reducing suicidal behavior in these patients is limited. The objective of the present study was to evaluate the efficacy of the Attempted Suicide Short Intervention Program (ASSIP) in reducing suicidal behavior. ASSIP is a novel brief therapy based on a patient-centered model of suicidal behavior, with an emphasis on early therapeutic alliance.
Patients who had recently attempted suicide were randomly allocated to treatment as usual (n = 60) or treatment as usual plus ASSIP (n = 60). ASSIP participants received three therapy sessions followed by regular contact through personalized letters over 24 months. Participants considered to be at high risk of suicide were included, 63% were diagnosed with an affective disorder, and 50% had a history of prior suicide attempts. Clinical exclusion criteria were habitual self-harm, serious cognitive impairment, and psychotic disorder. Study participants completed a set of psychosocial and clinical questionnaires every 6 months over a 24-month follow-up period. The study represents a real-world clinical setting at an outpatient clinic of a university hospital of psychiatry. The primary outcome measure was repeat suicide attempts during the 24-month follow-up period. Secondary outcome measures were suicidal ideation, depression, and health-care utilization. Furthermore, effects of prior suicide attempts, depression at baseline, diagnosis, and therapeutic alliance on outcome were investigated. During the 24-month follow-up period, five repeat suicide attempts were recorded in the ASSIP group and 41 attempts in the control group. The rates of participants reattempting suicide at least once were 8.3% (n = 5) and 26.7% (n = 16). ASSIP was associated with an approximately 80% reduced risk of participants making at least one repeat suicide attempt (Wald χ21 = 13.1, 95% CI 12.4-13.7, p < 0.001). ASSIP participants spent 72% fewer days in the hospital during follow-up (ASSIP: 29 d; control group: 105 d; W = 94.5, p = 0.038). Higher scores of patient-rated therapeutic alliance in the ASSIP group were associated with a lower rate of repeat suicide attempts. Prior suicide attempts, depression, and a diagnosis of personality disorder at baseline did not significantly affect outcome. Participants with a diagnosis of borderline personality disorder (n = 20) had more previous suicide attempts and a higher number of reattempts. Key study limitations were missing data and dropout rates. Although both were generally low, they increased during follow-up. At 24 months, the group difference in dropout rate was significant: ASSIP, 7% (n = 4); control, 22% (n = 13). A further limitation is that we do not have detailed information of the co-active follow-up treatment apart from participant self-reports every 6 months on the setting and the duration of the co-active treatment.
ASSIP, a manual-based brief therapy for patients who have recently attempted suicide, administered in addition to the usual clinical treatment, was efficacious in reducing suicidal behavior in a real-world clinical setting. ASSIP fulfills the need for an easy-to-administer low-cost intervention. Large pragmatic trials will be needed to conclusively establish the efficacy of ASSIP and replicate our findings in other clinical settings.
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02505373.
自杀未遂是自杀及反复自杀未遂的主要危险因素。然而,关于后续治疗能否减少这些患者自杀行为的证据有限。本研究的目的是评估自杀未遂短期干预项目(ASSIP)在减少自杀行为方面的疗效。ASSIP是一种基于以患者为中心的自杀行为模型的新型简短疗法,强调早期治疗联盟。
近期有自杀未遂行为的患者被随机分配至常规治疗组(n = 60)或常规治疗加ASSIP组(n = 60)。ASSIP组参与者接受三次治疗,随后在24个月内通过个性化信件进行定期联系。纳入被认为有高自杀风险的参与者,63%被诊断为情感障碍,50%有既往自杀未遂史。临床排除标准为习惯性自我伤害、严重认知障碍和精神障碍。研究参与者在24个月的随访期内每6个月完成一套心理社会和临床问卷。该研究代表了一家大学精神病医院门诊的真实临床环境。主要结局指标是24个月随访期内的反复自杀未遂情况。次要结局指标是自杀意念、抑郁和医疗服务利用情况。此外,还研究了既往自杀未遂、基线抑郁、诊断和治疗联盟对结局的影响。在24个月的随访期内,ASSIP组记录到5次反复自杀未遂,对照组记录到41次。至少有一次反复自杀未遂的参与者比例分别为8.3%(n = 5)和26.7%(n = 16)。ASSIP使参与者至少有一次反复自杀未遂的风险降低了约80%(Wald χ21 = 13.1,95% CI 12.4 - 13.7,p < 0.001)。ASSIP组参与者在随访期间住院天数减少了72%(ASSIP组:29天;对照组:105天;W = 94.5,p = 0.038)。ASSIP组患者评定的治疗联盟得分较高与反复自杀未遂率较低相关。既往自杀未遂、抑郁以及基线时人格障碍的诊断对结局无显著影响。诊断为边缘性人格障碍的参与者(n = 20)有更多既往自杀未遂和更高的反复自杀未遂次数。主要研究局限性是数据缺失和失访率。虽然两者总体较低,但在随访期间有所增加。在24个月时,两组失访率差异显著:ASSIP组为7%(n = 4);对照组为22%(n = 13)。另一个局限性是,除了参与者每6个月关于协同治疗的设置和持续时间的自我报告外,我们没有关于协同后续治疗的详细信息。
ASSIP是一种针对近期有自杀未遂行为患者的基于手册化的简短疗法,在常规临床治疗基础上实施,在真实临床环境中能有效减少自杀行为。ASSIP满足了对易于实施的低成本干预措施 的需求。需要进行大型实用性试验来最终确定ASSIP的疗效,并在其他临床环境中复制我们的研究结果。
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02505373