Lowis M J, Mooney S
Department of Psychology, University College Northampton, England.
Percept Mot Skills. 2001 Oct;93(2):367-81. doi: 10.2466/pms.2001.93.2.367.
Research has yielded mixed support for graphological claims. The present study was designed to see whether specific components of students' handwriting were related to personality traits associated with achievement in written examinations. If aspects were identified that could be used to predict future academic performance, the findings would not only be of interest to graphologists but would be invaluable to both student and tutor in a teaching environment. In a blind trial, 100 handwriting samples from first-year scripts were analysed for the presence or absence of 12 graphological characteristics deemed to be relevant for academic performance, and each of these aspects was tested for association with the grade points awarded. Statistically significant differences were found for two of the 12 characteristics: "carefulness" and "constancy." Also, measurements of individual letters indicated that consistent slant was significantly associated with high grade points, whereas upright or mixed writing was not. These attributes appeared to be generally related to readability and aesthetic quality. Although such aspects might influence the grading of scripts by teachers, typed versions received similar grades to those awarded for the handwritten versions.
对于笔迹学的说法,研究结果喜忧参半。本研究旨在探讨学生笔迹的特定组成部分是否与书面考试成绩相关的人格特质有关。如果能找出可用于预测未来学业表现的因素,那么这一发现不仅笔迹学家会感兴趣,在教学环境中对学生和教师而言也将非常宝贵。在一项盲测中,对100份一年级学生笔迹样本进行分析,以确定是否存在12种被认为与学业表现相关的笔迹特征,并且对这些特征中的每一项与所授予的绩点进行关联性测试。在这12种特征中的两种上发现了具有统计学意义的差异:“仔细程度”和“连贯性”。此外,对单个字母的测量表明,书写倾斜度一致与高绩点显著相关,而书写垂直或倾斜度不一则不然。这些属性似乎通常与易读性和美观性有关。尽管这些方面可能会影响教师对笔迹的评分,但打印版本的得分与手写版本相近。