van Dijk J Marc C, TerBrugge Karel G, Willinsky Robert A, Wallace M Christopher
Division of Neurosurgery, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
J Neurosurg. 2002 Jan;96(1):76-8. doi: 10.3171/jns.2002.96.1.0076.
Dural arteriovenous fistulas (AVFs) are a well-known pathoanatomical and clinical entity. Excluding bilateral involvement of the cavernous sinus, multiple dural AVFs are rare, with isolated reports in the literature. The additional risk associated with multiplicity is unknown, although it has been claimed that there is a greater risk of hemorrhage at presentation. In a group of 284 patients with dural AVFs consecutively treated at a single center, the occurrence of multiplicity is investigated and its risk factors for hemorrhage are identified.
Among the 284 patients with both cranial and spinal dural AVFs, 20 patients with multiple fistulas were found. Nineteen (8.1%) of 235 patients with cranial AVFs had multiple cranial fistulas, and one (2%) of 49 patients with spinal AVFs harbored two spinal fistulas. Twelve patients were found to have a lesion at two separate sites, seven patients had them at three locations, and one patient had four fistulas, each at a different site. In the subgroup with multiple AVFs the percentage of hemorrhage at presentation was three times higher than in the entire group (p = 0.01). Cortical venous drainage in cranial fistulas was present in 84% of patients with multiple lesions compared with 46% of patients with solitary lesions (p < 0.005).
Multiple dural AVFs are not rare. In this group of 284 patients it was found in 8.1% of all patients with cranial dural AVFs. Multiplicity was associated with a higher percentage of cortical venous drainage, a pattern of drainage reportedly yielding a higher risk for hemorrhage.
硬脑膜动静脉瘘(AVF)是一种广为人知的病理解剖和临床实体。除海绵窦双侧受累外,多发硬脑膜AVF罕见,文献中仅有个别报道。尽管有人声称多发硬脑膜AVF在发病时出血风险更高,但与之相关的额外风险尚不清楚。在一家单一中心连续治疗的284例硬脑膜AVF患者中,对多发情况的发生率进行了调查,并确定了其出血的危险因素。
在284例同时患有颅部和脊髓硬脑膜AVF的患者中,发现20例有多发性瘘。235例颅部AVF患者中有19例(8.1%)有多个颅部瘘,49例脊髓AVF患者中有1例(2%)有两个脊髓瘘。发现12例患者在两个不同部位有病变,7例患者在三个部位有病变,1例患者有四个瘘,每个瘘位于不同部位。在多发AVF亚组中,发病时出血的百分比比整个组高出三倍(p = 0.01)。与单发病变患者的46%相比,多发病变患者中84%的颅部瘘存在皮质静脉引流(p < 0.005)。
多发硬脑膜AVF并不罕见。在这组284例患者中,在所有颅部硬脑膜AVF患者中有8.1%被发现。多发性与较高比例的皮质静脉引流相关,据报道这种引流模式会产生更高的出血风险。