Millet G P, Chollet D, Chalies S, Chatard J C
Laboratoire UPRES-EA Sport, Performance, Santé, Faculté des Sciences du Sport, 700 Avenue du pic Saint Loup, 34090 Montpellier, France.
Int J Sports Med. 2002 Feb;23(2):99-104. doi: 10.1055/s-2002-20126.
The aim of this study was to compare the arm coordination in 19 elite triathletes and 15 elite swimmers at six different velocities between 80 % and 100 % of their maximal velocity (Vmax). The different phases of the stroke (A: entry; B: pull; C: push; D: recovery) were identified by video analysis. An index of coordination (IdC) was calculated. It was the time that separated the beginning of the propulsive phase of one arm from the end of the propulsive phase of the other arm. IdC allows to express the mode of arm coordination: catch-up, IdC < 0; opposition, IdC = 0; superposition, IdC > 0. Between 80 % and 98 % Vmax, elite triathletes showed similar increases in IdC than swimmers (from -8.8 % to 2.6 % vs from -8.6 % to 0.3 %) switching from a catch-up to a superposition coordination. Between 88 % and Vmax, triathletes increased the propulsive phase (B+C) less (p < 0.01) than swimmers (3.4 % vs 8.5 %) and increased the recovery phase (0.8 %) when swimmers reduced it (-1.6 %). Between V5 and Vmax, both triathletes and swimmers had a significant (p < 0.01) difference in IdC change (-1.7 % vs 2.3 %). Moreover, triathletes reduced the propulsive phase when swimmers increased it (-0.6 % vs 3.2 %). The lower velocity of the triathletes was associated to a shorter stroke length when compared to the swimmers (1.70 m vs 2.15 m at Vmax). The stroke rates were not statistically different (55.1 vs 51.2 stroke x min(-1) at Vmax). Thus, monitoring IdC and stroke length is recommended for triathletes mainly at maximal velocity.
本研究的目的是比较19名精英铁人三项运动员和15名精英游泳运动员在其最大速度(Vmax)的80%至100%之间的六个不同速度下的手臂协调性。通过视频分析确定划水的不同阶段(A:入水;B:划水;C:推水;D:出水)。计算了协调性指数(IdC)。它是一只手臂推进阶段开始与另一只手臂推进阶段结束之间的时间。IdC可以表示手臂协调模式:追赶,IdC < 0;对抗,IdC = 0;叠加,IdC > 0。在80%至98% Vmax之间,精英铁人三项运动员的IdC增加情况与游泳运动员相似(从 -8.8% 至2.6%,而游泳运动员从 -8.6% 至0.3%),从追赶协调转变为叠加协调。在88%至Vmax之间,铁人三项运动员推进阶段(B + C)的增加幅度(p < 0.01)小于游泳运动员(3.4% 对8.5%),并且当游泳运动员减少恢复阶段(-1.6%)时,铁人三项运动员增加了恢复阶段(0.8%)。在V5至Vmax之间,铁人三项运动员和游泳运动员的IdC变化存在显著差异(p < 0.01)(-1.7% 对2.3%)。此外,当游泳运动员增加推进阶段时,铁人三项运动员减少了推进阶段(-0.6% 对3.2%)。与游泳运动员相比,铁人三项运动员较低的速度与较短的划水长度相关(Vmax时为1.70米对2.15米)。划水频率在统计学上没有差异(Vmax时为55.1次/分钟对51.2次/分钟)。因此,建议主要在最大速度下对铁人三项运动员监测IdC和划水长度。