Bates Elizabeth, Dick Frederic
Center for Research in Language and Department of Cognitive Science, University of California, San Diego, La Jolla, CA 92093-0526, USA.
Dev Psychobiol. 2002 Apr;40(3):293-310. doi: 10.1002/dev.10034.
Do language abilities develop in isolation? Are they mediated by a unique neural substrate, a "mental organ" devoted exclusively to language? Or is language built upon more general abilities, shared with other cognitive domains, and mediated by common neural systems? Here, we review results suggesting that language and gesture are "close family", then turn to evidence that raises questions about how real those "family resemblances" are, summarizing dissociations from our developmental studies of several different child populations. We then examine both these veins of evidence in light of some new findings from the adult neuroimaging literature and suggest a possible reinterpretation of these dissociations as well as new directions for research with both children and adults.
语言能力是孤立发展的吗?它们是由独特的神经基质介导的吗,即一个专门用于语言的“心理器官”?还是语言建立在与其他认知领域共享的更一般能力之上,并由共同的神经系统介导?在这里,我们回顾了表明语言和手势是“近亲”的研究结果,然后转向提出有关这些“家族相似性”有多真实的问题的证据,总结我们对几个不同儿童群体的发育研究中的分离现象。然后,我们根据成人神经成像文献中的一些新发现来审视这两条证据脉络,并提出对这些分离现象的可能重新解释以及针对儿童和成人研究的新方向。