Schreiber Martin A, Holcomb John B, Conaway Cass W, Campbell Kyle D, Wall Matthew, Mattox Kenneth L
Michael E. DeBakey Department of Surgery, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, Texas 77030, USA.
J Surg Res. 2002 May 1;104(1):8-14. doi: 10.1006/jsre.2002.6391.
In 1996, Congress passed legislation requiring the Department of Defense to conduct trauma training in civilian hospitals. In September of 1998 an Army team composed of surgeons, nurses, emergency medical technicians (EMTs), and operating room technicians (OR techs) trained in a civilian level 1 trauma center. This study analyzes the quality of the training.
The training period was 30 days. Before and after training all members completed a questionnaire of their individual and team ability to perform at their home station, at the civilian hospital, and in the combat setting. Surgeons maintained an operative log, which was compared with their prior year's experience. Primary trauma cases (PTCs) met Residency Review Committee criteria as defined category cases and were done acutely. Other personnel tracked the percentage of supporting soldier tasks (SSTs) they performed or were exposed to during the training period.
Review of the questionnaires revealed a significant increase in confidence levels in all areas tested (P < 0.005). The three general surgeons performed a total of 42 PTCs during the 28 call periods, or 1.5 PTCs per call period. During the prior year, the same three general surgeons performed 20 PTCs during 114 call periods for 0.175 cases per call period (P = 0.003). The maximum number of PTCs performed during one call period at the civilian center was 4, compared with 5 PTCs performed by one Army surgeon during the Somalia 1993 mass casualty event. Performance of or exposure to SSTs was 71% for the EMTs, 94% for the nurses, and 79% for the OR techs.
A 1-month training experience at a civilian trauma center provided military general surgeons with a greater trauma experience than they receive in 1 year at their home station. Other personnel on the team benefited by performing or being exposed to their SSTs. Further training of military teams in civilian trauma centers should be investigated.
1996年,国会通过立法,要求国防部在民用医院开展创伤培训。1998年9月,一支由外科医生、护士、急救医疗技术员(EMT)和手术室技术员(OR技师)组成的陆军团队在一家民用一级创伤中心接受培训。本研究分析了培训质量。
培训期为30天。培训前后,所有成员都填写了一份关于他们在驻地、民用医院和战斗环境中个人及团队执行任务能力的问卷。外科医生保留了一份手术记录,并与他们上一年的经验进行比较。主要创伤病例(PTC)符合住院医师评审委员会定义的类别病例标准,并为急症手术。其他人员记录了他们在培训期间执行或接触到的支援士兵任务(SST)的百分比。
对问卷的审查显示,所有测试领域的信心水平都有显著提高(P < 0.005)。三位普通外科医生在28个值班期间共进行了42例PTC,即每个值班期间1.5例PTC。上一年,这三位普通外科医生在114个值班期间进行了20例PTC,每个值班期间0.175例(P = 0.003)。在民用中心,一个值班期间进行的PTC最多为4例,而1993年索马里大规模伤亡事件期间,一名陆军外科医生进行了5例PTC。EMT执行或接触SST的比例为71%,护士为94%,OR技师为79%。
在民用创伤中心进行1个月的培训经历,为军队普通外科医生提供了比他们在驻地1年所获得的更多的创伤治疗经验。团队中的其他人员通过执行或接触SST而受益。应研究军队团队在民用创伤中心的进一步培训。