Murray W R, Rodrigo J J
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1975 Dec;57(8):1060-5.
Arthrography in twenty-five painful hips of twenty-one patients after total hip replacement and in fifty-three asymptomatic hips of forty-two patients after this procedure showed that arthrographic evidence of loosening was not always associated with pain. More than one-fifth of the asymptomatic hips had arthrographic evidence of loosening. Furthermore, the loosening shown by arthrogram could be confirmed in only seven of twelve hips that were subsequently explored. In addition, there was no apparent relationship between arthrographic loosening and the presence of a Trendelenburg sign. This study casts doubt on the value of an arthrogram in the diagnosis of the cause of pain after total hip replacement.
对21例患者25个全髋关节置换术后疼痛髋关节及42例患者53个无症状髋关节进行关节造影,结果显示关节造影显示的松动证据并不总是与疼痛相关。超过五分之一的无症状髋关节有关节造影显示的松动证据。此外,在随后接受探查的12个髋关节中,只有7个髋关节的关节造影显示的松动得到了证实。另外,关节造影显示的松动与臀中肌麻痹步态征的存在之间没有明显关系。这项研究对关节造影在诊断全髋关节置换术后疼痛原因方面的价值提出了质疑。