Timmins Caraway L
Yale University, USA.
J Midwifery Womens Health. 2002 Mar-Apr;47(2):80-96. doi: 10.1016/s1526-9523(02)00218-0.
Although Spanish was the primary language of an estimated 11 % of adults in the year 2000, the U.S. health care system is largely geared toward serving English speakers. A systematic review was conducted of studies published in biomedical journals from 1990 to 2000 examining language barriers in health care for Latino populations. Aspects of the problem examined were access to health care, quality of care, and health status/health outcomes. Five (55%) of the nine studies examining access to care found a significant adverse effect of language; three (33%) found mixed or weak evidence that language affected access. Six (86%) of the seven studies evaluating quality of care found a significant detrimental effect of language barriers. Two of the three studies examining health status or outcomes found language to be a risk factor for adverse outcomes. Evidence was mixed as to the level of importance attributable to language when access to care is considered; however, non-English-speaking status was a marker of a population at risk for decreased access. Solid evidence showed that language barriers can adversely affect quality of care. Health care practitioners are recommended to devise an effective strategy to bridge language barriers in their setting. National laws and policies are discussed; practical guidelines and resources for providing language access in health care are provided. This article is intended to supply basic knowledge for providers and institutions in devising effective strategies for bridging the language barrier.
尽管在2000年估计有11%的成年人以西班牙语为主要语言,但美国的医疗保健系统在很大程度上是为服务说英语的人而设计的。对1990年至2000年发表在生物医学期刊上的研究进行了系统综述,这些研究探讨了拉丁裔人群在医疗保健中的语言障碍。所研究的问题包括获得医疗保健的机会、医疗质量以及健康状况/健康结果。在九项研究获得医疗保健机会的研究中,有五项(55%)发现语言有显著的不利影响;三项(33%)发现有混合或微弱的证据表明语言影响获得医疗保健的机会。在七项评估医疗质量的研究中,有六项(86%)发现语言障碍有显著的不利影响。在三项研究健康状况或结果的研究中,有两项发现语言是不良结果的一个风险因素。在考虑获得医疗保健机会时,关于语言的重要程度的证据不一;然而,不会说英语的状况是获得医疗保健机会减少的高危人群的一个标志。确凿的证据表明,语言障碍会对医疗质量产生不利影响。建议医疗保健从业者制定一项有效的策略,以消除他们所在环境中的语言障碍。文中讨论了国家法律和政策;提供了在医疗保健中提供语言服务的实用指南和资源。本文旨在为提供者和机构提供基础知识,以便制定消除语言障碍的有效策略。