Madigan Elizabeth A, Tullai-McGuinness Susan, Neff Donna Felber
International Health Programs, Frances Payne Bolton School of Nursing, Case Western Reserve University, USA.
Annu Rev Nurs Res. 2002;20:267-91.
This chapter reviews 69 published research reports of home health care from a health services perspective by nurse researchers and researchers from other disciplines. Reports were identified through searches of the National Library of Medicine (MEDLINE), and the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature and Social Sciences Citation Index using the following search terms: home health care, health services research, and elders. Within the major areas identified, the following additional terms were specified: resource use and outcomes. Reports were included if published between 1995 and 2001, used samples age 65 and older, performed in the U.S., and published in English. Studies of all types were included. The key findings follow: (a) Most studies were a theoretical. If a theoretical model was used, it was most often the Andersen Behavioral Model. (b) Few conclusions can be drawn about resource use--increasing age and higher severity of health related problems are associated with higher numbers of home visits. The variety of measures of resource use and the study approaches (large national data sets versus single or several agency samples) limits the ability to draw conclusions on resource use. (c) There is a growing body of evidence on rehospitalization of home health care patients which indicates rehospitalization is prevalent but largely not predictable. (d) Patient outcomes research is inconclusive at this point, primarily because there are few studies that examine patient outcomes using a consistent set of measures. The main recommendations are: to study rehospitalization using a more profile-based approach to determine visit patterns that may be effective, to further specify the kinds of outcomes that may be achieved as a result of home health care and which patients might be expected to achieve positive outcomes, and to examine the integration of home health care with the broader community-based services.
本章从卫生服务的角度回顾了护士研究人员以及其他学科研究人员发表的69篇关于家庭医疗保健的研究报告。这些报告是通过使用以下检索词在国立医学图书馆(MEDLINE)、护理及相关健康文献累积索引和社会科学引文索引中检索确定的:家庭医疗保健、卫生服务研究和老年人。在确定的主要领域内,还指定了以下附加检索词:资源利用和结果。如果报告发表于1995年至2001年之间,使用65岁及以上的样本,在美国进行,并且以英文发表,则纳入研究。纳入了所有类型的研究。主要研究结果如下:(a)大多数研究没有理论依据。如果使用了理论模型,最常用的是安德森行为模型。(b)关于资源利用几乎无法得出结论——年龄增长和与健康相关问题的严重程度增加与家访次数增多有关。资源利用的各种衡量方法以及研究方法(大型国家数据集与单个或多个机构样本)限制了就资源利用得出结论的能力。(c)越来越多的证据表明家庭医疗保健患者再次住院的情况,这表明再次住院很普遍,但在很大程度上无法预测。(d)目前患者结局研究尚无定论,主要是因为很少有研究使用一套一致的衡量标准来检查患者结局。主要建议如下:采用更基于概况的方法研究再次住院情况,以确定可能有效的家访模式,进一步明确家庭医疗保健可能实现的结局类型以及哪些患者可能有望取得积极结局,并研究家庭医疗保健与更广泛的社区服务的整合情况。