Inglis F
Glasgow Memory Clinic, Clydebank, Scotland, UK.
Int J Clin Pract Suppl. 2002 Jun(127):45-63.
Cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEIs) are dosed in two phases for the treatment of dementia, an initial dose-escalation phase to achieve a therapeutic dose and a maintenance phase where the therapeutic dose is given for long-term therapy. ChEIs are associated with a range of side effects as a result of cholinergic stimulation in different areas of the brain and the periphery Acute, centrally-mediated gastrointestinal events (mostly nausea and vomiting) are class effects of all ChEIs, and are reported mostly during the dose-escalation phase of therapy. These events have been associated more with the dual acetylcholinesterase/butyrylcholinesterase (AChE/BuChE) inhibitor rivastigmine than with the AChE-selective inhibitors donepezil and galantamine, probably due to rivastigmine's higher potency. However, these events can be minimised using slow dose escalation with small dose graduations and administration with food. Other side effects associated with ChEIs include central nervous system events, extrapyramidal symptoms, sleep disturbances and cardiorespiratory events, associated with cholinergic activity in the cortex, caudate nucleus, brainstem and medulla, respectively, and muscle cramps and weakness, cardiorespiratory events and urinary incontinence, associated with peripheral cholinergic activity. These symptoms are mostly reported during the maintenance phase of therapy. They are more frequently reported with donepezil, but are rarely reported with rivastigmine, and galantamine may not have been marketed long enough to make an adequate assessment. These differences are due to the drugs' respective pharmacology. For example, donepezil and rivastigmine are active centrally, in contrast to galantamine, which is more active peripherally. Furthermore, rivastigmine preferentially inhibits the G1 isoform of cholinesterase, predominantly located in the cortex, hippocampus and in neuritic plaques, while donepezil and galantamine are not selective for any cholinesterase isoforms and have wide cholinergic activity both centrally and peripherally The cholinergic activity of rivastigmine, in contrast to donepezil and galantamine, is apparently more targeted at clinically relevant brain sites. The pharmacological profile of rivastigmine results in it having a low potential to interact with other drugs and it may be used with a high margin of safety in patients having a wide variety of concomitant diseases. Donepezil and galantamine may have significant interactions with other drugs that are metabolised by the hepatic cytochrome system and therefore need to be used with caution in patients with many concomitant illnesses. When dosed with care, ChEIs are well tolerated and patient compliance and patient and caregiver acceptability are good. The favourable tolerability and safety profiles of these agents make them suitable first-line therapy for dementia. In addition, patients who have tolerability and/or safety problems in maintenance treatment that limit the use of donepezil or galantamine may benefit from switching to rivastigmine.
胆碱酯酶抑制剂(ChEIs)用于治疗痴呆症时分为两个阶段给药,即初始剂量递增阶段以达到治疗剂量,以及维持阶段,在此阶段给予治疗剂量进行长期治疗。由于胆碱能刺激在大脑和外周的不同区域发挥作用,ChEIs会引发一系列副作用。急性的、中枢介导的胃肠道事件(主要是恶心和呕吐)是所有ChEIs的类效应,大多在治疗的剂量递增阶段出现。与双重乙酰胆碱酯酶/丁酰胆碱酯酶(AChE/BuChE)抑制剂卡巴拉汀相比,这些事件与AChE选择性抑制剂多奈哌齐和加兰他敏的关联度较低,这可能是因为卡巴拉汀的效力更高。然而,通过缓慢递增剂量、小剂量梯度给药以及与食物同服,可以将这些事件的发生几率降至最低。与ChEIs相关的其他副作用包括中枢神经系统事件、锥体外系症状、睡眠障碍和心肺事件,分别与皮质、尾状核、脑干和延髓中的胆碱能活性有关,以及肌肉痉挛和无力、心肺事件和尿失禁,与外周胆碱能活性有关。这些症状大多在治疗的维持阶段出现。多奈哌齐更常出现这些症状,而卡巴拉汀很少出现,加兰他敏上市时间可能不够长,无法进行充分评估。这些差异归因于药物各自的药理学特性。例如,多奈哌齐和卡巴拉汀在中枢具有活性,而加兰他敏在外周更具活性。此外,卡巴拉汀优先抑制胆碱酯酶的G1同工型,主要位于皮质、海马体和神经炎性斑块中,而多奈哌齐和加兰他敏对任何胆碱酯酶同工型均无选择性,在中枢和外周均具有广泛的胆碱能活性。与多奈哌齐和加兰他敏相比,卡巴拉汀的胆碱能活性显然更针对临床相关的脑区。卡巴拉汀的药理学特性使其与其他药物相互作用的可能性较低,在患有多种合并症的患者中使用时安全性较高。多奈哌齐和加兰他敏可能与其他经肝细胞色素系统代谢的药物发生显著相互作用,因此在患有多种合并症的患者中使用时需谨慎。如果谨慎给药,ChEIs耐受性良好,患者依从性以及患者和护理人员的接受度都很高。这些药物良好的耐受性和安全性使其成为痴呆症的合适一线治疗药物。此外,在维持治疗中存在耐受性和/或安全性问题而限制使用多奈哌齐或加兰他敏的患者,改用卡巴拉汀可能会受益。