Hipwell Alison E, Loeber Rolf, Stouthamer-Loeber Magda, Keenan Kate, White Helene R, Kroneman Leoniek
Department of Psychiatry, Western Psychiatric Institute and Clinic, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15213, USA.
Crim Behav Ment Health. 2002;12(1):99-118. doi: 10.1002/cbm.489.
Crime, particularly among juvenile females, has increased in recent years. Little is known, however, about the development and precursors in childhood of female delinquent behaviour. This is primarily due to a lack of consensus on how to define and assess female antisocial behaviour, and a lack of studies using sufficiently large samples.
A community sample of 2451 girls between the ages of five and eight years were recruited into a longitudinal study following the enumeration of 103,238 households in the city of Pittsburgh. Data on disruptive and antisocial behaviours were collected from parents, teachers and children during the first wave of the study.
Prevalence rates of disruptive disorders varied by choice of informants and measurement thresholds. The prevalence of most disruptive behaviours was similar across the four age cohorts. Where there were differences, parents of younger girls tended to report fewer problematic behaviours compared with parents of older girls. Teachers reported more disruptive behaviours than parents and, by their reports, older girls were more likely to show oppositional/defiant behaviour and relational aggression than younger girls. Girls scoring highly on several domains relative to their peers were over-represented in disadvantaged neighbourhoods.
A range of disruptive disorders are present among a subgroup of females at an early age, particularly among girls in the most disadvantaged neighbourhoods. Longitudinal follow-up is required to examine the developmental trajectories and predictive utility of these behaviours. The implications for clinical interventions are discussed.
近年来,犯罪率有所上升,尤其是在青少年女性中。然而,对于女性犯罪行为在儿童期的发展及其先兆,我们知之甚少。这主要是由于在如何定义和评估女性反社会行为方面缺乏共识,以及缺乏使用足够大样本的研究。
在对匹兹堡市103,238户家庭进行普查后,招募了2451名年龄在5至8岁之间的女孩作为社区样本,纳入一项纵向研究。在研究的第一阶段,从家长、教师和儿童那里收集了关于破坏性行为和反社会行为的数据。
破坏性行为障碍的患病率因信息提供者的选择和测量阈值而异。在四个年龄组中,大多数破坏性行为的患病率相似。存在差异的地方在于,与年龄较大女孩的家长相比,年龄较小女孩的家长报告的问题行为较少。教师报告的破坏性行为比家长更多,而且根据他们的报告,年龄较大的女孩比年龄较小的女孩更有可能表现出对立违抗行为和关系攻击行为。在一些领域得分相对于同龄人较高的女孩在弱势社区中占比过高。
在一小部分女性中,尤其是在最弱势社区的女孩中,存在一系列破坏性行为障碍。需要进行纵向随访,以研究这些行为的发展轨迹和预测效用。文中还讨论了对临床干预的影响。