Marusic Andrej, Tavcar Rok, Dernovsek Mojca, Steblaj Tone
Institute of Psychiatry, King's College London, UK.
Nord J Psychiatry. 2002;56(5):335-8. doi: 10.1080/080394802760322097.
We compared main characteristics of 58 (22 male and 36 female) psychiatric inpatients that committed suicide in the psychiatric hospital with all 1261 suicides (956 male and 305 female) that occurred outside hospitals in the same health district of Slovenia, all these in the period between 1985 and 1993. The independent t-test and cross-tabulation were used to compare the two groups on age, sex, marital status and suicide method profile. It appeared that female suicide is much more frequent in the psychiatric inpatients' group than in others. Only male psychiatric inpatients' suicides are younger than other suicide victims. Psychiatric inpatients use methods like jumping from high places and drowning more often than do others, which goes in line with the availability of methods of suicide. Apparently, the studied hospital has some wards on the third floor and majority of acute wards are located by the river. However, psychiatric inpatients do not differ from other suicide victims on marital status. Higher suicide rates in men compared with women in the population, but not in psychiatric inpatients, could be explained by the presence of so-called atypical, clinically unrecognized depression in the male population.
我们比较了1985年至1993年期间,斯洛文尼亚同一健康区58名(22名男性和36名女性)在精神病院自杀的精神科住院患者的主要特征,与所有1261名(956名男性和305名女性)在医院外自杀的人员的特征。使用独立样本t检验和交叉表来比较两组在年龄、性别、婚姻状况和自杀方式方面的情况。结果显示,女性自杀在精神科住院患者组中比在其他组中更为常见。只有男性精神科住院患者的自杀年龄比其他自杀受害者年轻。精神科住院患者比其他人更常使用从高处跳下和溺水等自杀方式,这与自杀方式的可得性相符。显然,所研究的医院有一些三楼的病房,且大多数急性病房位于河边。然而,精神科住院患者在婚姻状况方面与其他自杀受害者并无差异。总体人群中男性自杀率高于女性,但在精神科住院患者中并非如此,这可能是由于男性群体中存在所谓的非典型、临床未被识别的抑郁症。