Cohen Mark D, Draxler Roland R, Artz Richard, Commoner Barry, Bartlett Paul, Cooney Paul, Couchot Kim, Dickar Alan, Eisl Holger, Hill Catherine, Quigley James, Rosenthal Joyce E, Niemi David, Ratté Dominique, Deslauriers Marc, Laurin Rachelle, Mathewson-Brake Larissa, McDonald John
NOAA Air Resources Laboratory, Silver Spring, Maryland 20910, USA.
Environ Sci Technol. 2002 Nov 15;36(22):4831-45. doi: 10.1021/es0157292.
Atmospheric deposition is a significant loading pathway for polychlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxins and dibenzofurans (dioxin) to the Great Lakes. An innovative approach using NOAA's HYSPLIT atmospheric fate and transport model was developed to estimate the 1996 dioxin contribution to each lake from each of 5,700 point sources and 42,600 area sources in a U.S./Canadian air emissions inventory. These unusually detailed source-receptor modeling results show that deposition to each lake arises from a broad geographical region, with significant contributions from up to 2,000 km away. The source categories contributing most significantly to 1996 dioxin deposition appear to be municipal waste incineration, iron sintering, medical waste incineration, and cement kilns burning hazardous waste. Model-predicted air concentrations and deposition fluxes were consistent with ambient measurement data, within the uncertainties in each, but there may be a moderate tendency toward underestimation using midrange emissions estimates. The most likely reason for this tendency appears to be missing or underestimated emissions sources, but in-situ atmospheric formation of octachlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxin (OCDD) and heptachlorinated dibenzo-p-dioxin (HpCDD) may have also contributed. Despite uncertainties, the findings regarding the relative importance of different sources types and source regions appear to be relatively robust and may be useful in prioritizing pollution prevention efforts.
大气沉降是多氯二苯并对二恶英和多氯二苯并呋喃(二恶英)进入五大湖的重要输入途径。开发了一种利用美国国家海洋和大气管理局(NOAA)的HYSPLIT大气归宿和传输模型的创新方法,以估算1996年美国/加拿大空气排放清单中5700个点源和42600个面源对每个湖泊的二恶英贡献。这些异常详细的源-受体模型结果表明,每个湖泊的沉降来自广泛的地理区域,距离达2000公里处有显著贡献。对1996年二恶英沉降贡献最大的源类别似乎是城市垃圾焚烧、铁烧结、医疗垃圾焚烧以及燃烧危险废物的水泥窑。模型预测的空气浓度和沉降通量在各自的不确定性范围内与环境测量数据一致,但使用中等范围排放估计可能存在适度低估的趋势。这种趋势最可能的原因似乎是排放源缺失或被低估,但八氯二苯并对二恶英(OCDD)和七氯二苯并对二恶英(HpCDD)的原位大气形成也可能有贡献。尽管存在不确定性,但关于不同源类型和源区域相对重要性的研究结果似乎相对可靠,可能有助于确定污染预防工作的优先顺序。