Côtè James E, Schwartz Seth J
Department of Sociology, University of Western Ontario, London, Ont, Canada N6A 5C2.
J Adolesc. 2002 Dec;25(6):571-86. doi: 10.1006/jado.2002.0511.
Psychologists have been studying identity processes at the intrapsychic level that resemble what sociologists have noted at the macro-societal level. Specifically, using the identity capital model introduced in previous issues of this journal (Côté, Journal of Adolescence, 19, 419-430; 20, 421-437), we explore a link between the psychologically oriented identity status paradigm, and the sociologically oriented individualization theory. The primary link between these two disciplinary approaches appears to be that the individualization process can be operationalized in terms of agency in identity formation. The relationship between agency and identity formation has been recognized by identity status researchers for some time, but primarily in terminology referring to the intrapsychic level; hence, in some respects, identity status researchers anticipated individualization theory. This link was empirically investigated in three studies of ethnically diverse samples. It was concluded, with a high degree of replication, that the identity statuses representing identity confusion (Diffusion) and identity synthesis (Achievement) appear to represent forms of default and developmental individualization, respectively. This comparison of similar elements between psychological and sociological perspectives may yield a richer understanding of identity formation processes, and help to pave the way for future interdisciplinary research..
心理学家一直在研究个体心理层面的认同过程,这些过程类似于社会学家在宏观社会层面所指出的情况。具体而言,我们运用本期刊前几期所介绍的认同资本模型(科特,《青少年杂志》,第19卷,第419 - 430页;第20卷,第421 - 437页),探讨了以心理学为导向的认同状态范式与以社会学为导向的个体化理论之间的联系。这两种学科方法之间的主要联系似乎在于,个体化过程可以根据认同形成中的能动性来进行操作化。认同状态研究者在一段时间内已经认识到能动性与认同形成之间的关系,但主要是在涉及个体心理层面的术语中;因此,在某些方面,认同状态研究者早于个体化理论。这种联系在三项针对不同种族样本的研究中得到了实证调查。通过高度的重复验证得出结论,代表认同困惑(弥散状态)和认同整合(成就状态)的认同状态似乎分别代表了默认个体化和发展性个体化的形式。这种对心理学和社会学视角中相似元素的比较,可能会让我们对认同形成过程有更丰富的理解,并有助于为未来的跨学科研究铺平道路。