Grassi C, Casali L, Curti E, Tellarini M, Lazzaro C, Schito G
Pneumology Department, University of Pavia, Italy.
J Chemother. 2002 Dec;14(6):597-608. doi: 10.1179/joc.2002.14.6.597.
The aim of this multicenter, open, randomized study was to compare the efficacy and tolerability of a 5-day treatment course with oral moxifloxacin (MXF) vs a 7-day course with i.m. ceftriaxone (CRO) in 476 patients with acute exacerbations of chronic bronchitis (AECB), and to conduct a cost minimization analysis of the two treatments from the perspectives of both the Italian National Health Service (INHS) and society. The study was conducted in Italy. Clinical success rates at test-of-cure in the 423 patients of the PP (Per Protocol) population (primary efficacy parameter) were 90.6% and 89.0% for MXF and CRO, respectively. Statistical non-inferiority of MXF vs CRO was confirmed. Similar results were found between study drugs on the secondary efficacy parameters, including success at end-of-treatment (95.3% for MXF vs 92.9% for CRO), success at test-of-cure in bacteriologically-positive patients (94.1% vs 90.7%) and eradication/presumed eradication rates (91.7% vs 93.3%). ITT (Intention-to-Treat) analysis confirmed these data. There was a low incidence of adverse events (10.8% vs 9.1%). During a 6-month follow-up period, relapse rates were lower for MXF vs CRO (23.3% vs 28.3%; p > .05). Compared with CRO, MXF was associated with cost savings per patient ranging from Euro226.57 (INHS perspective) to Euro448.23 (societal perspective), with lower hospitalization rate the major variable contributing to reduced costs. MXF appears to be an ideal candidate for AECB treatment.
这项多中心、开放性、随机研究的目的是比较476例慢性支气管炎急性加重期(AECB)患者口服莫西沙星(MXF)5天疗程与肌肉注射头孢曲松(CRO)7天疗程的疗效和耐受性,并从意大利国家医疗服务体系(INHS)和社会的角度对两种治疗方法进行成本最小化分析。该研究在意大利进行。符合方案(PP)人群中423例患者(主要疗效参数)的治疗结束时临床成功率,MXF组和CRO组分别为90.6%和89.0%。证实了MXF相对于CRO的统计学非劣效性。在次要疗效参数方面,研究药物之间也发现了类似结果,包括治疗结束时的成功率(MXF组为95.3%,CRO组为92.9%)、细菌学阳性患者治疗结束时的成功率(94.1%对90.7%)以及根除/假定根除率(91.7%对93.3%)。意向性分析(ITT)证实了这些数据。不良事件发生率较低(10.8%对9.1%)。在6个月的随访期内,MXF组的复发率低于CRO组(23.3%对28.3%;p>.05)。与CRO相比,MXF使每位患者节省的成本从226.57欧元(INHS角度)到448.23欧元(社会角度)不等,较低的住院率是成本降低的主要变量。MXF似乎是AECB治疗的理想选择。