Blumer Dietrich, Davies Keith, Alexander Alan, Morgan Stacy
Epilepsy Behav. 2001 Oct;2(5):466-472. doi: 10.1006/ebeh.2001.0249.
Purpose. The goal of this work was documentation of incidence, phenomenology, pathogenesis, and treatment of psychiatric disorders occurring subsequent to treating epilepsy by vagus nerve stimulation (VNS).Methods. In a series of 81 patients treated by VNS, all patients who developed major psychiatric complications underwent systematic psychiatric evaluation and treatment with psychotropic medication; VNS was modified if necessary.Results. After the seizure frequency was reduced by at least 75%, 7 of 81 patients (9%) developed major psychiatric disorders: Six became severely dysphoric (5 with catastrophic rage and 4 with psychotic symptoms), and one became psychotic. All 7 patients had experienced dysphoric disorders and 2 had experienced psychotic episodes prior to the VNS treatment. Five patients had frequent daily seizures prior to treatment. Remission or satisfactory improvement was achieved with psychotropic medication in 6 patients, aided by decreasing or interrupting VNS in two patients. One patient was noncompliant and suffered a fatal outcome.Conclusion. Severe interictal dysphoric disorders associated with catastrophic rage and psychotic episodes may develop on suppressing seizures by VNS in patients with previous epilepsy-related psychiatric disorders. Patients with multiple daily seizures may be more vulnerable to this occurrence. The phenomenon corresponds to the common finding of interictal dysphoric and psychotic symptoms emerging when inhibitory mechanisms predominate (alternative psychiatric disorders in the absence of seizures, or forced normalization of the EEG). The dysphoric symptom of catastrophic rage appears to occur more often on seizure suppression by VNS than by antiepileptic drugs. Psychiatric intervention, primarily with antidepressant medication, must be available to secure a good outcome; decrease of VNS may occasionally be required.
目的。本研究旨在记录迷走神经刺激(VNS)治疗癫痫后发生的精神障碍的发病率、症状学、发病机制及治疗方法。
方法。在一组接受VNS治疗的81例患者中,所有出现严重精神并发症的患者均接受了系统的精神评估,并使用精神药物进行治疗;必要时对VNS进行调整。
结果。在癫痫发作频率至少降低75%后,81例患者中有7例(9%)出现了严重精神障碍:6例出现严重烦躁不安(5例伴有灾难性愤怒,4例伴有精神病性症状),1例出现精神病性症状。所有7例患者在VNS治疗前均有烦躁不安障碍,2例曾有过精神病性发作。5例患者在治疗前每天癫痫发作频繁。6例患者通过精神药物治疗实现了缓解或明显改善,其中2例通过减少或中断VNS得到了帮助。1例患者不配合治疗,最终死亡。
结论。对于既往有癫痫相关精神障碍的患者,VNS抑制癫痫发作时可能会出现与灾难性愤怒和精神病性发作相关的严重发作间期烦躁不安障碍。每日癫痫发作多次的患者可能更容易出现这种情况。这种现象与抑制机制占主导时出现的发作间期烦躁不安和精神病性症状的常见发现相符(无癫痫发作时的交替性精神障碍,或脑电图的强制正常化)。与抗癫痫药物相比,VNS抑制癫痫发作时灾难性愤怒的烦躁不安症状似乎更常出现。必须进行精神科干预,主要使用抗抑郁药物,以确保良好的治疗效果;偶尔可能需要减少VNS。